Benellis58 GIB bashing on repeat Groundhog Day
#841
Posted 2026-March-13, 18:09
Declarer takes 10 tricks, rolling home with his game. If the clown in the East had played a heart at trick three, declarer would have had no play. The GIBBO robots continue to be hopeless embarrassments.
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/y7bw5hh9
#842
Posted 2026-March-13, 18:18
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/yckm8u96
#843
Posted 2026-March-13, 18:23
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/2p8uefzn
#844
Posted 2026-March-13, 18:33
Then when West leads a club against South's 2S, East wins his king and says, "No thanks, I don't WANT a third round club ruff". He then...cashes his ace of hearts...AND switches to a diamond to make CERTAIN that he won't - even by accident - get that third round club ruff that he so DESPERATELY wants to avoid. Hopeless...as ALWAYS.
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/5n88dpmh
#845
Posted 2026-March-13, 18:38
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/2p99rfwp
#847
Posted 2026-March-13, 19:36
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/6tc9u6wx
#848
Posted 2026-March-14, 13:12
We'll start with some GIBBO "logic". East passes North's 1H. I guess he feels he doesn't have the values to compete. But not too long after that, he doubles TWO hearts for takeout. Oh yeah, that's REALLY consistent - NOT. And oh yeah, that's REALLY logical - NOT. And oh yeah, that's really intelligent - NOT. In other words, it's TYPICAL of GIBBO "thinking".
Then West freely bids 3S on his 4-3-3-3 bland 5-count ALL in QUACKS.
Whether they get a top or a bottom, their bidding is as "good" as usual. They scored 28.6 % on the board.
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/2p83bsut
#849
Posted 2026-March-14, 13:22
At trick 6, West COVERS dummy's club jack with his queen, which can't be right.
At the end of the hand, the GIBBO robots write a zero in their scorecards and congratulate each other on adding to their lifelong collection of them...likely the largest of its kind in the entire world.
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/2p933eya
#850
Posted 2026-March-14, 14:12
I do NOT, however, question the wisdom of the GIB definition. Why not? Because I don't have to "question" it - I know it's pure, unadulterated garbage! Here it is, in all its profound ugliness: "Invitational to 3NT game: 2-6 clubs; 2-6 diamonds; 2-5 hearts; 2-4 spades; 10- HCP; 12+ total points; stop in clubs".
Even by the wretched "standards" of GIB definitions - the lowest of the low - this is award-winningly pathetic (2026 Oscar for Worst Definition of the Year), so let's rip it to shreds, piece by revolting piece.
"Invitational to 3NT game". First, there is no need in Heaven or Earth to include that unnecessary and truly annoying word "game". I suspect that BBO players are already AWARE that 3NT is game. Is the word included SOLELY to insult us all? Next: It is BEYOND stupid to declare that this call is inviting 3NT! Prior to EW entering the auction, South had opened 1H, North had responded 1S, South had bid 1NT, and North had...PASSED! He was VERY happy to let the auction END with his partner South declaring a contract of ONE no trump...even though the EW opponents had done nothing but pass. How on Earth...and WHY on Earth could he NOW be inviting THREE no trump? This type of total GARBAGE is sadly an excellent illustration of why the GIB definitions are so often worthy of contempt, scorn, and ridicule.
"2-6 clubs". Reality check time! If he had SIX clubs, would he have PASSED 1NT? If he had SIX clubs, and knowing that his partner had at least TWO clubs, would he be...in the PASSOUT seat...RESCUING his LHO from a 2C contract? Perhaps NOT, Mr. GIB! What IGNORANCE!
"2-6 diamonds". Reality check time...again! If he had SIX diamonds, would he have PASSED 1NT? If he had SIX diamonds, and knowing that his partner had at least TWO diamonds, if he wanted to compete against East's 2C contract, would he not bid two...DUH...DIAMONDS rather than 2NT?
"2-5 hearts". Reality check time...YET again! If he had FIVE hearts, would he not at some point have SUPPORTED hearts, the suit his partner South OPENED?
"2-4 spades". Good GRIEF...it's reality check time...YET again! If he had two...or three spades, why the HELL would he have responded one SPADE (!!!) to partner's 1H opening bid?
"10- HCP". This literally means zero to ten, since the LAZY definition gives no lower limit. EVEN if he had TEN, why would he be inviting 3NT? And obviously with FEWER than ten, it would be even crazier.
"12+ total points". TOTAL points? How? Why? Where did this figure COME from, Mr. GIB? Show your work. Show your logic. Show your REASON for making this unscientific, specious claim! And why is the subject of "total" points even IN the discussion, since he is bidding NO TRUMP?
"Stop in clubs". NO! J76 is NOT a "stop in clubs"...ESPECIALLY after an opponent just BID the suit! Maybe it's a partial stop, but that's not what this pathetic definition syas.
GIB definitions are OFTEN pure garbage, but this one takes the cake as one of the worst pieces of nonsense I have ever seen EVEN from GIB!
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/5n9atpdk
#851
Posted 2026-March-14, 14:45
https://tinyurl.bridgebase.com/4z58j4p
#852
Posted 2026-March-14, 14:48
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/2w4nc73z
#853
Posted 2026-March-14, 15:21
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/5n6d7jdn
#854
Posted 2026-March-14, 15:36
West has only TWO hearts, K4 doubleton. His partner East's 2H call could have been made on "only" a FIVE-card suit...so what the HELL does "The Law" have to do with this, and why the HELL would West think that East-West have "TEN" trumps (hearts) between them? In practice, they have ONLY eight, and West is lucky they have THAT many, because they MIGHT have had only seven!
Also, West, for his 4H bid, is SUPPOSED to have "3+ hearts". Three...PLUS? He doesn't even have THREE - he has TWO!
And look at that typical stupidity in the GIB definition: "16- total points". That literally means ZERO to 16, so it's so vague and wide-ranging that it's completely useless. The definition is laughable trash. The BID doesn't come close to matching the definition. All very typical for the hopeless GIBBO robots and the pathetic GIB definitions.
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/mpkw68dv
#855
Posted 2026-March-14, 15:42
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/3yfpzstr
#856
Posted 2026-March-14, 16:31
Have I ever mentioned that the GIBBO robots absolutely ROT? Oh, I have? Sorry for the repetition then.
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/y79u2der
#857
Posted 2026-March-14, 16:42
West is on lead with 87, AK982, 10732, Q4. He leads the 8...of SPADES. Declarer takes TEN tricks.
I hope you're sitting down, because what I'm about to reveal next might SHOCK you! Okay, comfortable? Good. Here's the SHOCKING news: a HEART lead would have held declarer to a mere EIGHT tricks, but how could East EVER have known to lead a heart rather than a spade?
What's that you say? Anyone but a total ***** (such as a GIBBO robot!) would have led a HEART and held the contract to EIGHT tricks? Golly gee, I think you're right! They are SO bad!
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/yr4j7cd7
#858
Posted 2026-March-14, 16:47
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/35zmpscf
#859
Posted Yesterday, 11:42
Besides the inherent stupidity of this craven panic attack, here's a suggestion for this jerk: If he's GOING to STUPIDLY want to "rescue" his "partner" in such situations, maybe he should bid two DIAMONDS over pard's 1S, and then if he still wants to perform his maniacal "rescue", he can bid 3C over 2S. That way he has at LEAST shown his shape and West can at LEAST have the option of choosing to play at the three level in any of FIVE strains, depending on his hand.
Needless to say, East's magnificently stupid 3H bid did not match his own GIB definition. The GIBBO robots are hopeless. Sorry, I realize that's not exactly a groundbreakingly original observation.
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/y8apt33b
#860
Posted Yesterday, 12:13
https://tinyurl.brid...se.com/37wuk8ww

Help
