My robot partner bid well for once, but on trick 3 why fly the ace when East had shown the works and doubled our spades?
See here
Page 1 of 1
Does GiB listen to the auction?
#3
Posted Yesterday, 03:13
kerkido, on 2026-November-20, 20:09, said:
Doesn't 3♦ show a very weak hand in the robot's system? Along with the ace of clubs, if it's listening to the auction it probably thinks the ♠K is very unlikely.
Yes the bot will fail to understand 3♦ by a pair who do not play cue raises as Advancer, fair point (not that a for payment robot should be assuming opponents play its own system, but that is what we get). But the same player went on to bid game in diamonds and then double game in spades, which is not showing a weak hand.
East has shown more vacant spades than West.
There are also obvious practical issues in playing for the K in West, even if you think it is probable for some reason. He is going to win it anyway, unless we lay down the A hoping for a stiff, as the bot did. A priori that was 12% or so?
#4
Posted Yesterday, 06:47
Hello! Perhaps I'm missing something since I am only an intermediate bridge player. But as the cards lay, doesn't it make 5 spades?
Finesse 3 spades in east and play for KJ hearts in east. It seems like that is the only lay of the cards that would allow NS to make the contract. It loses the Ace clubs and a heart?
If that is the only reasonable way for NS to make the contract is by assuming that distro, why wouldn't robot play for that? A low probability, I grant you, but a low probability is better than a very low probability, which seems to be the case by assuming a stiff king of spades in west and KJ hearts in east anyway (otherwise, it likely loses two heart tricks rather than one.)
It seems a strange play by robot. Might there be some programming "under the hood" that is not a immediately apparent that drove that play decision? Best regards. Mike
Finesse 3 spades in east and play for KJ hearts in east. It seems like that is the only lay of the cards that would allow NS to make the contract. It loses the Ace clubs and a heart?
If that is the only reasonable way for NS to make the contract is by assuming that distro, why wouldn't robot play for that? A low probability, I grant you, but a low probability is better than a very low probability, which seems to be the case by assuming a stiff king of spades in west and KJ hearts in east anyway (otherwise, it likely loses two heart tricks rather than one.)
It seems a strange play by robot. Might there be some programming "under the hood" that is not a immediately apparent that drove that play decision? Best regards. Mike
#5
Posted Yesterday, 07:01
msheald, on 2026-November-21, 06:47, said:
Hello! Perhaps I'm missing something since I am only an intermediate bridge player. But as the cards lay, doesn't it make 5 spades?
Finesse 3 spades in east and play for KJ hearts in east. It seems like that is the only lay of the cards that would allow NS to make the contract. It loses the Ace clubs and a heart?
If that is the only reasonable way for NS to make the contract is by assuming that distro, why wouldn't robot play for that? A low probability, I grant you, but a low probability is better than a very low probability, which seems to be the case by assuming a stiff king of spades in west and KJ hearts in east anyway (otherwise, it likely loses two heart tricks rather than one.)
It seems a strange play by robot. Might there be some programming "under the hood" that is not a immediately apparent that drove that play decision?
Finesse 3 spades in east and play for KJ hearts in east. It seems like that is the only lay of the cards that would allow NS to make the contract. It loses the Ace clubs and a heart?
If that is the only reasonable way for NS to make the contract is by assuming that distro, why wouldn't robot play for that? A low probability, I grant you, but a low probability is better than a very low probability, which seems to be the case by assuming a stiff king of spades in west and KJ hearts in east anyway (otherwise, it likely loses two heart tricks rather than one.)
It seems a strange play by robot. Might there be some programming "under the hood" that is not a immediately apparent that drove that play decision?
Kerkido's suggestion (which may well be correct) is that the robot misunderstood 3♦ as a weak raise and was unable to change that idea even when East bid game and doubled 5♠, so having seen the clubs Ace concluded that East could not have spades King as well and therefore played West for a stiff as the only hope of dropping King.
Whatever is going on, the result is not competent bridge.
#6
Posted Yesterday, 07:26
Thanks! One of the problems of robot play compared to F2F play, I think. In a tournament, I would have asked ops what the 3D bid meant in their system so that there would any doubt in my mind.
As I thought about this more, perhaps it has to do with what declarer might do if the initial line of attack fails? For example, if there is not a stiff king, does declarer have to hope for a stiff ace of hearts to make the contract?
Similarly, if the spade finesse fails, is the only line of play the hope that there is a stiff king of hearts?
So, if the backup play is the same, what is the chance that there is a stiff king spades vs. a finessable king of spades? And, how might vulnerability affect this decision? For example, if north/south had been looking at a vulnerable game, perhaps east/west was looking at a sacrifice? It would be curious to see the odds of the spade king location given these scenarios, both if there had been no double and after a double.
And, as you noted, would not even a novice player take the location of the double into account when trying to identify the location of the spade king? Best regards. Mike
As I thought about this more, perhaps it has to do with what declarer might do if the initial line of attack fails? For example, if there is not a stiff king, does declarer have to hope for a stiff ace of hearts to make the contract?
Similarly, if the spade finesse fails, is the only line of play the hope that there is a stiff king of hearts?
So, if the backup play is the same, what is the chance that there is a stiff king spades vs. a finessable king of spades? And, how might vulnerability affect this decision? For example, if north/south had been looking at a vulnerable game, perhaps east/west was looking at a sacrifice? It would be curious to see the odds of the spade king location given these scenarios, both if there had been no double and after a double.
And, as you noted, would not even a novice player take the location of the double into account when trying to identify the location of the spade king? Best regards. Mike
#7
Posted Yesterday, 11:01
pescetom, on 2026-November-20, 15:57, said:
My robot partner bid well for once, but on trick 3 why fly the ace when East had shown the works and doubled our spades?
See here
See here
Well if it was planning on finessing it should be leading Queen of spades
As it is it has to play for 3-0 split to make
Sarcasm is a state of mind
Page 1 of 1

Help
