Posted 2005-April-23, 12:14
The 2nd one is rather easy. All you have to do is avoid cashing the A♦ early and ruff 2 diamonds in dummy. When you lead a trump off the board, RHO has the stiff A.
The 1st one is a bear. Brian ruffed the diamond in dummy, and played ♥AK, and ♥ overruffed by LHO with the J, down 1.
It looks like the right play is to ruff and play the ♠A, ♥AK and ♣AKQ dumping 3 of the ♦'s. You have to guess which round suit to ruff to get back to your hand to ruff the last diamond, ruff the last diamond and have to guess for the last time how to get back to your hand.
It may be right or wrong, but when you take that last ruff back to your hand, its a 2-way finesse for the King! You have the option of ruffing with the 9 or Q. Odd.
LHO had J8 and RHO had Kx. Even with this layout, RHO can ruff high and play the heart to promote the J.
Another oddity of the hand is the falsecard of the Jack(!) on the play of the Ace. This will certainly lead declarer down the wrong path.
Rebound, leading the Q♠ probably isn't a good idea. Even if it gets covered and you win, you have to leave the ♠J - 8 outstanding. You can't ruff 2 ♦'s in dummy now and have to rely on a 3rd ♥ or a 4th ♣ for your 12th trick.
Even then its a complex hand, and I wouldn't be surprised if it turned out to be the best play, with all of the trump promotion issues with the crossruff.
Hands like this are a sheer headache!
"Phil" on BBO