Since I play the latter I can only say this has not been a problem. We just assume partner has the minimum nt type hand and bid accordingly. Keep in mind that for me 2/1 shows 14+ hcp...not some 11 pt hand. That means if opener has extra's he knows responder has a decent hand. In practice opener so seldom has extras it is tough to remember when he did have support for D and extras. Often I just pray he has at least 11.
boring 2/1 hand
#41
Posted 2007-October-12, 17:42
Since I play the latter I can only say this has not been a problem. We just assume partner has the minimum nt type hand and bid accordingly. Keep in mind that for me 2/1 shows 14+ hcp...not some 11 pt hand. That means if opener has extra's he knows responder has a decent hand. In practice opener so seldom has extras it is tough to remember when he did have support for D and extras. Often I just pray he has at least 11.
#42
Posted 2007-October-12, 17:48
pclayton, on Oct 12 2007, 02:48 AM, said:
awm, on Oct 11 2007, 09:59 PM, said:
I'd like to be able to show a diamond fit at some point, but I want to slow down the auction since my hand is pretty bad and my diamond fit is not so great either.
The nice thing about 2♠ is that partner will often try 2NT next and I can show my diamond support next without overstating matters by raising directly. There are a fair number of hands that would rebid 3♦ or 3nt over 2nt, but will bid 2nt over 2♠. I don't think 2♠ rebid shows six, and my five-card suit is good enough that I can easily imagine a 5-2 spade fit being our best game.
Same here.
same here
In one current partnership, partner likes 2♠ to show 6, and he'd bid 2N... until we had a long discussion, after which he now rebids 2♠ as do my other regular partners.. but he would still bid 2N with others.
2♠ is a style choice. I and (obviously) other 2♠ bidders believe that, when one has to make a 'neutral' waiting bid, it is usually more efficient that this bid be the cheaper of two possibilities. Thus 2♠ affords room for a forcing 2N over which we have an easy 3♦ bid, and partner can hardly go wrong.. if he is concerned that we have 6 spades, as indeed we could, he'll bid 3♠ on the way to 3N if that is where we are going. If he has slam ambitions, we usually have room to work out what to do.
#43
Posted 2007-October-12, 18:05
That being said, as few of us like 2♦ after 2♣ to be diamonds or balanced. The cheaper call, below two of our major. If you like a 2♠ waiting call after a 2♦ (or 2♥) response, then I'm sure you would see the even more beneficial 2♦ rebid as appealing, eh?
--------------
Did I mention that an immediate 3♦ call is sick? LOL
-P.J. Painter.
#44
Posted 2007-October-12, 23:15
For us, 3D is a hand that shows real D support, not a flat hand like the posted one.
To Helene: "Over a 2♣ response I would say that 2♠ should promise 6 in American style (not in French style) because you're allowed to rebid 2D on a 3-card as the most convenient bid."
This is illogical. What do you bid with a 5 3 2 3 shape ? Using your argument, you have to raise to 3C.
#45
Posted 2007-October-12, 23:22
- hrothgar
#46
Posted 2007-October-12, 23:28
Hannie, on Oct 13 2007, 12:22 PM, said:
You have it right; 3C is an ask.
Over this 3NT shows the 18-19 balanced hand, and is forcing to 4NT with various continuations over 3NT.
4x, (or 3S if you opened 1H), over the 3C ask shows a one loser s/suiter with a low mid high s/t/void.
There are numerous other follow ups.
#47
Posted 2007-October-13, 01:58
The_Hog, on Oct 13 2007, 07:15 AM, said:
This is illogical. What do you bid with a 5 3 2 3 shape ? Using your argument, you have to raise to 3C.
Or 2N. If 2N promises extras, obviously you can't play it that way. You could bid 2♦ on a doubleton, would be OK with me but not with a pick-up partner of course.
3♣ on a 3-card would be revolting, though. Then rather 2♠.
Just my personal opinion.
#48
Posted 2007-October-13, 05:02
zasanya, on Oct 12 2007, 04:58 PM, said:
There is no problem with 6 cards, 2♠ leaves you plenty of space to find out, responder will tend to rebid 2NT wich doesn't show much, but asks further.
I must admit I've had problems diferentiating 6 spades from 7 spades, it had not created heavy problems just yet, but it can.
ArtK78, on Oct 12 2007, 4:39 AM, said:
WTF???
mike777, on Oct 12 2007, 11:31 AM, said:
1s=2d
3nt show with no special agreements or conventions?
I realised I have no agreements, 2NT just shows 15+ for me, I don't like to preempt myself with unnecesary jumps. 3NT could have 2 meanings, void splinter or 7 solid cards in spades (for MP).

Help
