I wouldn't even have bid 3N.. that's how clear it is to me not to bid slam.
He needs a perfect hand for you to make 3N.
He is highly unlikely to deliver a second spade stop, and you then need to run the diamonds (Axx is not enough to assure you of that) and still have another fast trick.
I'd have bid 3N at imps, but would have passed 3
♦ at mps unless I needed a great board and was willing to risk a poor one in the effort to get it.
I am fascinated by the idea that we are 90% sure all we can make is 5
♦. Just what kind of hand are we expecting, where LHO didn't raise spades, RHO didn't preempt, partner made a non-forcing 3
♦ and yanked my 3N?
Show me a hand on which this auction makes sense... and we can make 11 tricks in diamonds, let alone 12???
I could play partner to be an idiot, and to have pulled when 3N was making, but why? Is it clear that 3N even had a play?
BTW, just how smooth was my 3N bid??? The auction is highly suggestive of a slow 3N (not surprising given my view of its merits) and a pull based on that break in tempo... pulling 3N to 4
♦ is just such an odd call.
Anyway, I pass 4
♦
BTW, just read adam's post. Where does he find opps who are sworn to silence on that layout??? They have 17 major suit cards Including the AQJ of one suit and the AKQ of the other, either both have stiff diamonds, or one has a void, and they have the majority of the hcp and they never made a bid other than 1
♠???? Wow.
'one of the great markers of the advance of human kindness is the howls you will hear from the Men of God' Johann Hari
1♦-(P)-1♥-1♠
2♦-(P)-3♦-(P)
3NT-(P)-4♦-(P)
?