Posted Yesterday, 09:51
This is about as far from an intermediate play problem as one can get,
At the table, with no clue from opposition bidding, I think the best line at trick two is clear. There are two ways spades could be 3-0 and 6 ways they could be 2-1. And there’s a fairly easy line available if they are 2-1, so it seems silly not to approach the hand on that basis, always having a fall back position if they are 3-0.
I now know that south pitches on the first spade…why a diamond is another question. My plan would have been, had spades split, to cross to dummy at trick 2, ruff a club, back to dummy in trump, ruff another club and then the top hearts and a heart ruff. I’d be in dummy with xx void 109 J and void x AkJx void in hand. I pitch a diamond on the penultimate trump. If north has 4+ hearts, I have a double squeeze, on the reasonable assumption that South has the club king.
But the 3-0 trump break ruins this plan since I have to use one of my own high spades to pull a round of trump. I lose a dummy entry. Ordinarily I’d think that this means having to take the diamond hook and I’d want to do it before cashing my top hearts, so that I can untangle the suit if north covered to first diamond….as he should if I don’t have transportation. But souths pitch of a diamond worries me. It will more often than not be from a five card suit. Is there anything I can do about it, since if he has five diamonds, it’s very likely he has the Queen?
At trick 3, ruff a club, cash a high spades, and play north for 4+ hearts…likely if south is 5=5 in the minors as the diamond pitch suggests. So top hearts, ruff a heart, ruff a club with my last trump, ruff the last heart. In dummy with A void 109 J opposite void void AKJx void
The play of the spade Ace crushes south.
This line requires north to hold 4+ hearts, since otherwise we can’t ruff a second heart in dummy without being overruffed.
The inference about the diamond suit isn’t overwhelmingly strong but Manfield wrote a series of articles in The Bridge World, many years ago, about the ‘idle 5th’ card and one of his ideas is that most defenders will unthinkingly make their first pitch (if not signalling for something specific) from a suit in which they hold five cards and declarer is known not to have five himself…that fifth spot card will never have material value so it’s an easy one to pitch.
I’ve noticed, over the years, that this idea has considerable validity and I’m going to apply it here. If it works, I’ll refrain from thanking South.
'one of the great markers of the advance of human kindness is the howls you will hear from the Men of God' Johann Hari