3NT hand
My premise is any beginner would return suit led by partner (♦)
Is this unreasonable?
Can anyone explain Gibs logic?
Page 1 of 1
Defense so easy beginner wout set 3NT
#2
Posted 2019-January-06, 21:03
Clearly GIB East missorted its hand and had ♦3 in with the hearts.
Maybe GIB would have continued diamonds if you played the ♦2 showing 5 when East cashed ♦A? It's really just a guess with GIB
Maybe GIB would have continued diamonds if you played the ♦2 showing 5 when East cashed ♦A? It's really just a guess with GIB
#4
Posted 2019-January-07, 02:19
GIB does stupidly lead 4 from 754, which is probably the most likely holding for West given sims prove passive leads work better, after which a heart is sometimes a trick better than a diamond. But obviously, a diamond should still work better on average - unless there was a fluke in the sims which caused the other scenarios to never come up.
Page 1 of 1