sceptic, on Feb 7 2005, 02:56 AM, said:
ok, next question, I read (mike lawrence) saying never let opps play at the two level (I try and abide to this most of the time) would x be a good balance as opposed to the 2 spade bid????
What ML (and most competitive bidding books) says is "never let opps play at the two level" IF THEY HAVE A FIT.
If they have a fit, most of the time, we have a fit too, and it's our job to discover it.
If they do not have a fit, better let them play, doubled or undoubled, according to the combined strength and defensive tricks.
In some cases, the fit is explicit (opps bid+raise), in some others you can gues wheter or not they have a fit, analyzing the auction.
In this auction:
1- they did not bid and raise; so the fit is not guaranteed, neither for their side, nor for our side;
2- by looking at your hand and the bidding, you can estimate that it is a no-fit
auction. In fact, pard has denied a fit in clubs (he would have raised at least at the second round) and a 5 card spades.
3- in one of the suit of opps you have strength and length (AKxx in H), usually a sign of misfit, and an indication to defend
4- in the other suit, diamonds, you have Qxx, a doubtful value in offense, another indication suggesting to defend
5- if opps had a decent fit in diamond, pard would be short in D, and, having adequate strength, would have certainly supported clubs or would have 5+ spades (since he is certainly short in H);
6- 4333 hands are not well suited to compete; some people deduct 0.5-1 hcp for this shape; some others consider 4 cd support in 4333 = 3 card support, 3 cd support in 4333 = 2 cd support, etc, because of no ruffing values.
I cannot say whether this is going too far, but I think that usually, the 4333 bidder is better off leaving any aggressive decisions to his pard, who's the only one that might have the suitable distribution for aggressive bids; 4333 hand are happy to sit fo defense.
7- finlly, would DBL be a good balancing bid ? I do not think so; you have moe or less bid your hand, and you have little extra. Actually, your pard did overbid with his negative double and as a consequence you may be thinking that your side has the balance of power; still, pard, with an invitational hand and no fit, would have bid a second card-showing double or 2NT. I think the safest course is pass and defend.
"Bridge is like dance: technique's important but what really matters is not to step on partner's feet !"