Why should 4♠ be limited to 12- total points? What am I supposed to do with a slightly stronger hand, like the one here? 3♠ (instead of 4♠) was explained as 3+S and 12- total points.
Page 1 of 1
Responding to Michaels
#2
Posted 2012-October-10, 04:00
Why should 4♠ be limited to 12- total points? What am I supposed to do with a slightly stronger hand, like the one here? 3♠ (instead of 4♠) was explained as 3+S and 12- total points.
[/quote]
Why does it matter- more TP is not needed to reach a better contract- you need controls to get slam(those diamond HCP aren't worth much though the major's HCP are gold) ? Can you cue? What does 2NT (if natural then it should be conventional asking to clarify the strength of the hand) mean?
Give your hand just the Q of spades instead of Jack and then if North's void was in clubs then assuming he held the J of Diamonds then slam would be good- only minor changes whereas an extra K of clubs is of limited value.
[/quote]
Why does it matter- more TP is not needed to reach a better contract- you need controls to get slam(those diamond HCP aren't worth much though the major's HCP are gold) ? Can you cue? What does 2NT (if natural then it should be conventional asking to clarify the strength of the hand) mean?
Give your hand just the Q of spades instead of Jack and then if North's void was in clubs then assuming he held the J of Diamonds then slam would be good- only minor changes whereas an extra K of clubs is of limited value.
Page 1 of 1

Help

