[pigpenz]

♠ak74
♥k76
♦108754
♣8

auction:
1♣ 1♦ 2♣ 3♣
pass pass pass

this is ridiculous, when hands come up like this I just exit out of gib

[Bbradley62]

Unfortunately, when you "exit out" and then claim that things happened differently at your table than at all the others, it's hard to believe that you've got it right. At all the other tables, East bid 3♣, not South.
http://online.bridge...ername=pearl123

[pigpenz]

Bbradley62, on 2011-August-05, 18:44, said:

Unfortunately, when you "exit out" and then claim that things happened differently at your table than at all the others, it's hard to believe that you've got it right. At all the other tables, East bid 3♣, not South.
http://online.bridge...ername=pearl123

listen your comment makes no sense
left hand opened one club partner over called one diamond right hand opp bid 2 clubs not three clubs, giving me a chance to cue bid 3 clubs.
if it goes all pass after my cue bid that is assinine. is that fair then for all other people who are trying to get scores to compare against...come on get off your high horse.

there is something wrong with the bots when they do something ridiculous like that. it needs correction not someone with a holier than thou attiude.

I cant defend what the happened at the other tables only at mine and at my table my right hand gib bid 2 clubs only giving me the chance to bid 3 clubs. so if you take offense to my comments i apologize to you, but if something stupid like that happens i will not play the hand.

NOTE: you say you want bugs reported than thats what I would call this, you cue bidding the suit that opps have bid and raised and your partner GIB passing, not logical at all so must be a bug

[Bbradley62]

Just to clarify... As you can see, my "Group" is neither "Yellows" nor "Admin", so I am not a staff member.

[manudude03]

What Bbradley62 is saying is that what you're claiming and what the hand records are saying don't match. There were no 3C contracts by SOUTH.

[Bbradley62]

manudude03, on 2011-August-06, 10:00, said:

What Bbradley62 is saying is that what you're claiming and what the hand records are saying don't match. There were no 3C contracts by SOUTH.

Not quite. When he "exited", the hand at his table got aborted, so there is no record of what happened. I'm saying it would be nice for there to be a record.

[manudude03]

I thought if someone aborted a hand mid-deal, the appropriate hand record was blank, guess not.

[barmar]

Maybe in tourneys, but not in MBC.

[pigpenz]

barmar, on 2011-August-06, 14:20, said:

Maybe in tourneys, but not in MBC.

just seems what the point is why does gib pass a cue bid in a suit that the opponents open in and raise
if that is rational bridge then I am missing something this must be an error in the programming for gib

[barmar]

pigpenz, on 2011-August-08, 18:23, said:

just seems what the point is why does gib pass a cue bid in a suit that the opponents open in and raise
if that is rational bridge then I am missing something this must be an error in the programming for gib

Of course it's a programming error. But why did you quote my post, which was about whether aborted hands could be found in hand records?

[Bbradley62]

ok... at one other table, East bid 2♣ rather than 3♣:

---

[pigpenz]

barmar, on 2011-August-08, 23:08, said:

Of course it's a programming error. But why did you quote my post, which was about whether aborted hands could be found in hand records?

probably just hit a button and didnt look to see about quote thats why

[pigpenz]

Bbradley62, on 2011-August-09, 05:31, said:

ok... at one other table, East bid 2♣ rather than 3♣:

---

and so if south had bid 3♣ instead of 2♦ then all would be ok in the world of GIB for north to pass a 3♣ cue bid