[mtvesuvius]

This one is from a friend's table... At my table I raised to 4♥... How exactly are North's hearts "Strong rebiddable"?

---

Something went wrong with East GIB on Trick 5 -- I could see returning a spade if Greg had won the ♠Q at trick 1, however WGIB should know partner doesn't hold the ♠Q now, so their only shot is to return a club.

This post has been edited by mtvesuvius: 2011-July-17, 15:29

[Bbradley62]

mtvesuvius, on 2011-July-17, 10:55, said:

Something went wrong with West GIB on Trick 5 -- I could see returning a spade if Greg had won the ♠Q at trick 1, however WGIB should know partner doesn't hold the ♠Q now, so their only shot is to return a club.

Presumably, you mean EastGIB...

[mtvesuvius]

Bbradley62, on 2011-July-17, 15:18, said:

Presumably, you mean EastGIB...

Indeed -- Edited

[cloa513]

mtvesuvius, on 2011-July-17, 10:55, said:

This one is from a friend's table... At my table I raised to 4♥... How exactly are North's hearts "Strong rebiddable"?

---

Something went wrong with East GIB on Trick 5 -- I could see returning a spade if Greg had won the ♠Q at trick 1, however WGIB should know partner doesn't hold the ♠Q now, so their only shot is to return a club.

More in the cateogory of silly description- should be decent with rebiddable hand but North's clear rebid is 3♦ on which you will clearly bid 5♦ which only fails because the weak hand has an entry and hearts are 1-5, 4-2 would destroy 4♥ but still allow 5♦ to make