As the others have stated, a 2♠ rebid ( showing 5+cards ) by Responder (playing Lebensohl-- 2NT! here as the start of a sign-off) is forcing over a reverse.. It's close, but you just have enough to make that bid.
3♦ is also forcing and natural ( and not 4th suit forcing in the usual sense that it could be artificial -- 2S is enough to show 5 cards ) .... but Responder is not strong or shapely enough for a 3-level new suit rebid at this juncture.
1C - 1S
2H - 2S
3C - 3D
3NT
control / to play?
#22
Posted 2010-March-13, 17:59
I was responding to KQR's real auction. In that auction, 2S would no-longer show merely 5, but 6+, since opener denied 3 spades earlier. 2NT (less than 9 HCP) would not get a 3C rebid by opener, because his hand is too good. Thus, Opener can freely show his big hand and HX of spades by bidding 3S. That leads to a makable contract of 4S or 3NT.
You can keep your smug "ask the better players" remark to your self, Gibson.
You can keep your smug "ask the better players" remark to your self, Gibson.
"Bidding Spades to show spades can work well." (Kenberg)
#23
Posted 2010-March-13, 18:04
kgr, on Mar 13 2010, 11:11 PM, said:
Fluffy, on Mar 13 2010, 10:03 PM, said:
south is not close to 4♣ over 3♦, he should bid 3♠ or 3♥, he has 6 clubs, but they are awful, 3♠ bid its much better.
right (maybe 3♥ is best. The suit is good enough and less risks for misunderstanding. ...3♠ is also good to avoid 5-6 misunderstanding. Theoretically best I think)
Reading aquahombre I realice you play transfers over 1♣, 3♠ is mandatory then as he points out, south denied 3 spades and he has the best possible suppport now: Hx
Thx to the transfer you should land in 4♠. wich is the best spot.

Help
