How do you bit this hand playing a strong club with 1D reply = 0-7 points. If the bid is available West will bid 1/2S in the second round.
Page 1 of 1
How to bid this correctly?
#1
Posted 2009-November-29, 04:03
How do you bit this hand playing a strong club with 1D reply = 0-7 points. If the bid is available West will bid 1/2S in the second round.
#2
Posted 2009-November-29, 04:23
A few options here.
1) When I played strong club seriously I had the agreement not to open 1D with primary diamonds unless I had a GF in my own hand.
Therefore this sequence seems plausible.
1D (1S) 3D
3H 3S
4D P/5D depending on what mood responder is in.
2) If I have to open this 1C, then:
1C (1S) X
2D 3D
3H 3S
4D P/5D depending ....
I do feel I'm going to be in 5D off 1 a fairly high percentage of the time here.
1) When I played strong club seriously I had the agreement not to open 1D with primary diamonds unless I had a GF in my own hand.
Therefore this sequence seems plausible.
1D (1S) 3D
3H 3S
4D P/5D depending on what mood responder is in.
2) If I have to open this 1C, then:
1C (1S) X
2D 3D
3H 3S
4D P/5D depending ....
I do feel I'm going to be in 5D off 1 a fairly high percentage of the time here.
#4
Posted 2009-November-29, 07:12
If you open this hand 1♣ you better describe it as balanced. 1NT gives more room to p than 2♦.
1♣-1♦
1NT-(2♠)-3♦
3♠-4♣
5♦
3♦is invitational (a weak hand either passes or bid 2NT lebensohl).
3♠ asks for help in that suit. I think it doesn't show half a stopper here but of course it would be great if it did. Alternatively S could bid 3♥. That might show a 5-card to some, though, if you routinely rebid 1NT with a 5-card major. I don't think I would normally do that, though. So 3♥ is fine too, then responder could ask for half a stop with 3♠.
4♣ is natural, although S would generally pass without a diamond fit, clubs could still play better.
1♣-1♦
1NT-(2♠)-3♦
3♠-4♣
5♦
3♦is invitational (a weak hand either passes or bid 2NT lebensohl).
3♠ asks for help in that suit. I think it doesn't show half a stopper here but of course it would be great if it did. Alternatively S could bid 3♥. That might show a 5-card to some, though, if you routinely rebid 1NT with a 5-card major. I don't think I would normally do that, though. So 3♥ is fine too, then responder could ask for half a stop with 3♠.
4♣ is natural, although S would generally pass without a diamond fit, clubs could still play better.
The world would be such a happy place, if only everyone played Acol :) --- TramTicket
Page 1 of 1