mikeh, on Oct 17 2007, 01:45 AM, said:
Instead, he doubled and then jumped, so he does not have a one-dimensional hand. He has power.
Sure, the odds are that partner is broke or close to broke, but FP decisions are not made exclusively on high card strength. Advancer has NOT had a chance to describe his (weakish or worse) hand. He denied the ability to bid over 2♣, and could hardly be bidding over 4♥, but that still leaves a very wide range of hands.
The 4♥ bidder has a hand that may make 11 tricks in hearts opposite a suitable minimum and not get rich against 5♣.
This has all the hallmarks of a FP. The opps could have played 3♣. We bid a game in a power sequence... we clearly expected to make at least 10 tricks while the opps had contracted, voluntarily, for 9.
I will NEVER allow the speculation that the opps are walking the dog to deflect me from thinking logically about the hand. BTW, if they are walking the dog, then I assure you that 5♥ will be a cheap save
I agree with Mike here.
For me 4h comes from a powerhouse and I would not let the opponents play this undoubled.
If it's a make, ok, next one...
Alain

Help
