Late night decisions 2
#22
Posted 2007-October-16, 11:03
#23
Posted 2007-October-16, 11:08
cherdano, on Oct 16 2007, 09:03 AM, said:
Thats a pretty marginal 4♠ call, don't you think?
Isn't passing 4♥ x'd warranted with this soft 4=2=3=4?
#24
Posted 2007-October-16, 11:17
pclayton, on Oct 16 2007, 12:08 PM, said:
cherdano, on Oct 16 2007, 09:03 AM, said:
Thats a pretty marginal 4♠ call, don't you think?
Isn't passing 4♥ x'd warranted with this soft 4=2=3=4?
I don't think so (and what makes it soft? It has A K K with the jacks both support by a higher honor, and the 9 of each long suit.) The spades have some solidity and you have just xx of hearts. I would bid 4♠.
#25
Posted 2007-October-16, 11:24
jdonn, on Oct 16 2007, 09:17 AM, said:
pclayton, on Oct 16 2007, 12:08 PM, said:
cherdano, on Oct 16 2007, 09:03 AM, said:
Thats a pretty marginal 4♠ call, don't you think?
Isn't passing 4♥ x'd warranted with this soft 4=2=3=4?
I don't think so (and what makes it soft? It has A K K with the jacks both support by a higher honor, and the 9 of each long suit.) The spades have some solidity and you have just xx of hearts. I would bid 4♠.
That's defense young man. OK, it isn't soft, but it isn't exactly offensive with no known fit, and the death holding in their suit.
But I'll stay open-minded about this one.
#26
Posted 2007-October-16, 11:32
pclayton, on Oct 16 2007, 11:24 AM, said:
jdonn, on Oct 16 2007, 09:17 AM, said:
pclayton, on Oct 16 2007, 12:08 PM, said:
cherdano, on Oct 16 2007, 09:03 AM, said:
Thats a pretty marginal 4♠ call, don't you think?
Isn't passing 4♥ x'd warranted with this soft 4=2=3=4?
I don't think so (and what makes it soft? It has A K K with the jacks both support by a higher honor, and the 9 of each long suit.) The spades have some solidity and you have just xx of hearts. I would bid 4♠.
That's defense young man. OK, it isn't soft, but it isn't exactly offensive with no known fit, and the death holding in their suit.
But I'll stay open-minded about this one.
No known fit? What shape can partner have where we don't have a fit?
#27
Posted 2007-October-16, 11:36
#28
Posted 2007-October-16, 11:51
Jlall, on Oct 16 2007, 08:02 AM, said:
Cherdano, on Oct 16 2007, 09:03 AM, said:
Well, other than going down more on a bad break, is 4♠ really an inferior spot? In 5♣, you have to play spades for 1-loser. In 4♠ you can have two spade losers, but you also run the risk of losing control. So in the sense of going down in flames, 4♠ is worse than 5♣. But I'm not sure if it's worse for actually making game. (Although I'm sure someone will tell me.)
It's about what we expected though. I'm sure we can come up with hands where one black suit contract is great and the other has no chance, but I certainly agree that 5♣ is going to be safer.
#29
Posted 2007-October-16, 11:53
cherdano, on Oct 16 2007, 09:32 AM, said:
pclayton, on Oct 16 2007, 11:24 AM, said:
jdonn, on Oct 16 2007, 09:17 AM, said:
pclayton, on Oct 16 2007, 12:08 PM, said:
cherdano, on Oct 16 2007, 09:03 AM, said:
Thats a pretty marginal 4♠ call, don't you think?
Isn't passing 4♥ x'd warranted with this soft 4=2=3=4?
I don't think so (and what makes it soft? It has A K K with the jacks both support by a higher honor, and the 9 of each long suit.) The spades have some solidity and you have just xx of hearts. I would bid 4♠.
That's defense young man. OK, it isn't soft, but it isn't exactly offensive with no known fit, and the death holding in their suit.
But I'll stay open-minded about this one.
No known fit? What shape can partner have where we don't have a fit?
3=3=4=3? 3=3=5=2?
#30
Posted 2007-October-16, 11:58
Echognome, on Oct 16 2007, 11:51 AM, said:
Jlall, on Oct 16 2007, 08:02 AM, said:
Cherdano, on Oct 16 2007, 09:03 AM, said:
Well, other than going down more on a bad break, is 4♠ really an inferior spot? In 5♣, you have to play spades for 1-loser. In 4♠ you can have two spade losers, but you also run the risk of losing control. So in the sense of going down in flames, 4♠ is worse than 5♣. But I'm not sure if it's worse for actually making game. (Although I'm sure someone will tell me.)
If the spade queen is off-side, you go down most of the times in 4♠, and you have the risk of a club ruff. I guess you usually survive AQxx or Qxxx onside. It seems 5♣ is slightly better.
#31
Posted 2007-October-16, 12:00
cherdano, on Oct 16 2007, 09:58 AM, said:
If the spade queen is offside, how are you making 5♣?
#32
Posted 2007-October-16, 13:19
Echognome, on Oct 16 2007, 12:00 PM, said:
cherdano, on Oct 16 2007, 09:58 AM, said:
If the spade queen is offside, how are you making 5♣?
I never said that.
#33
Posted 2007-October-16, 13:28
cherdano, on Oct 16 2007, 11:19 AM, said:
Echognome, on Oct 16 2007, 12:00 PM, said:
cherdano, on Oct 16 2007, 09:58 AM, said:
If the spade queen is offside, how are you making 5♣?
I never said that.
Fair enough. What I had in mind was whether you could make 4♠ with the ♠Q off and spades 3-3?
#34
Posted 2007-October-16, 13:54
I'm not sure about 4♠ or 5♣. I think the odds will be close. However, the opponents tend to take sacrifices and save me when I bid 4♠ more than when I bid 5♣. "The five-level belongs to the opponents," and all. I would not terribly mind defending 5♥.
The point is that although 4♠ may or may not be an inferior contract to 5♣, I'd venture that the percentage increase of chances for 5♣ making when 4♠ does not is at least somewhat counter-balanced by the increased likelihood that we defend 5♥.
-P.J. Painter.
#35
Posted 2007-October-16, 13:57
kenrexford, on Oct 16 2007, 01:54 PM, said:
I'm not sure about 4♠ or 5♣. I think the odds will be close. However, the opponents tend to take sacrifices and save me when I bid 4♠ more than when I bid 5♣. "The five-level belongs to the opponents," and all. I would not terribly mind defending 5♥.
The point is that although 4♠ may or may not be an inferior contract to 5♣, I'd venture that the percentage increase of chances for 5♣ making when 4♠ does not is at least somewhat counter-balanced by the increased likelihood that we defend 5♥.
Hmm my opponents don't usually sacrifice when I am playing in a 4-3 fit. When I am in a 5-5 fit however...
#36
Posted 2007-October-16, 14:15
-P.J. Painter.
#37
Posted 2007-October-16, 14:17
kenrexford, on Oct 16 2007, 02:15 PM, said:
I guess I need to get your reputation as a solid bidder.
#38
Posted 2007-October-16, 14:23
- hrothgar

Help
