boring 2/1 hand
#22
Posted 2007-October-12, 09:15
ArtK78, on Oct 12 2007, 04:58 AM, said:
hrothgar, on Oct 12 2007, 07:50 AM, said:
2. A Diamond raise makes a lot of sense if you are considering investigating a Diamond slam. I would also chose a Diamond raise with Hxxx in support. Here you have a minimum opening where the primary concern is deciding between 3N and 4♠, with 5♦ a distant third. Both 2♠ and 2N provide much more bidding space for future exploration.
Partner knows whether he has 5 diamonds or not, and he should not expect more than 3 card support for my 3♦ bid.
And partner also knows whether he had game or slam in mind when he made his 2♦ call.
I have what I showed - an opening bid with support. My 3♦ bid does not promise extras.
I used to have this same opinion, but I've changed my outlook. 3♦ seems innocuous enough, but consider the situation from responder's side.
Lets say you hold a very ordinary 2=3=5=3.
1. Qx, xxx, AKQxx, Qxx. Do you try 3♠ looking for 3N if pard has stops in both pointed suits? Does 3♠ promise primary or secondary support? Do you just bypass 3N?
2. xx, xxx, AKJxx, KQx. You are really stuck here. 3N could be off the entire heart suit and there is no convenient way to show your club fragment.
3♦ should be reserved for non-minimums and should show 4 trump, or an exceptional hand with 3 trump. If the auction proceeds past 3N, opener should be willing to put down a dummy that is going to offer a better play for 5♦ than 3N, or have realistic hope that we might have a successful auction to 6♦.
2♠ or 2N is reasonable, and allows responder to bid out his hand. I personally like 2♠, since my stoppers are a little weak. Some have the agreement that 2N just shows a (5)332, and if thats the case, the call is fine.
#23
Posted 2007-October-12, 09:54
ArtK78, on Oct 12 2007, 07:58 AM, said:
hrothgar, on Oct 12 2007, 07:50 AM, said:
2. A Diamond raise makes a lot of sense if you are considering investigating a Diamond slam. I would also chose a Diamond raise with Hxxx in support. Here you have a minimum opening where the primary concern is deciding between 3N and 4♠, with 5♦ a distant third. Both 2♠ and 2N provide much more bidding space for future exploration.
Partner knows whether he has 5 diamonds or not, and he should not expect more than 3 card support for my 3♦ bid.
And partner also knows whether he had game or slam in mind when he made his 2♦ call.
I have what I showed - an opening bid with support. My 3♦ bid does not promise extras.
You are making serious light of the issues partner would have over 3♦. For one thing, yes he knows whether or not he has 5 diamonds, but if he doesn't then he would really like to know whether or not you have 3 or 4, and if you are raising with crappy 3 card support he will never know. Also he will have serious issues with something like Jx of hearts (look at Phil's post). You have two heart stoppers here and he doesn't know if you have any.
I find it funny that you say "every other bid is flawed", as I can not see a single flaw to either 2♠ or 2NT. The only one you might say is the Qx of clubs for 2NT, which for me is a definite positive not a negative. To each his own I guess, but implying there is no choice but 3♦? Find me the expert who would not bid 2♠ or 2NT.
#24
Posted 2007-October-12, 10:39
Hannie, on Oct 11 2007, 11:47 PM, said:
This was the problem hand as it was originally presented.
Does the absence of the ♥10 change your opinion any? It seems that you place a great deal of importance on partner's hypothetical holding of the Jx of hearts. If the ♥10 is not in dummy in 3NT, how do you like your heart stopper now (to say nothing of the club stopper)?
In any case, that is not my main concern. So many partnerships rely upon nebulous cue bids and nebulous rebids. Here, many say that 2♠ is the obvious rebid. In other words, 2♠ is a mark-time bid - saying nothing. That's fine if it is your agreement. In fact, many would make this bid. But why make a mark-time bid when you actually have a reasonable alternative, such as supporting partner? And while Jxx may not be your idea of support, it is mine.
Partner may assume that you do not have 6 spades or 3 diamonds for your 2♠ call. He may also assume that you do not have 4 of either of the rounded suits. Therefore, you should be 5323. He may bid 3NT without a club stopper (or with 3 small, which may be adequate opposite most 3 card holdings). That could easily prove to be wrong.
2NT has been advocated by many. Apparently, 2NT shows a balanced hand and does not promise stoppers in the unbid suits. 2NT is a practical bid (if you consider raising on Jxx as impractical), but it could easily lead to a 3NT contract with Qx of clubs facing xx or xxx.
Some state that 2♥ should be artificial over 2♦. That's fine if you like that sort of thing, but it is not a part of 2/1 game forcing. And every artificiality takes away something - in this case, a natural 2♥ call. I am sure that if opener's hand were AQTxx Axxx Jx Qx, everyone would bid 2♥ and no one would mention that it is artificial.
You may like 2♠, 2NT or an artificial 2♥. But don't say that each of those calls does not have its flaws.
I will admit that 3♦ also has flaws. While it does not show anything more than what I hold, partner might get too optimistic about slam prospects when he has good diamonds and a reasonble hand. But 3♦ does have the advantage of actually showing what you have.
It is clear that many of the posters are not completely familiar with 2/1 game forcing. A 2NT rebid does not show any extra values. It is purely descriptive. Similarly, a raise to 3♦ does not show any extra values. You are already in a game forcing auction - 3♦ just says that opener has support.
Clearly, I am in the minority on this one (a minority of one?). But at least I am giving everyone something to think about.
#25
Posted 2007-October-12, 10:46
ArtK78, on Oct 12 2007, 10:39 AM, said:
Uhm. Many pairs play 2/1 GF AND that a raise of partner's 2m bid shows extras. Maybe it is you who is not completely familiar with 2/1...
#26
Posted 2007-October-12, 10:51
OTOH here was written enough where you could have thought about but did not.
You say a 2 Spade bid shows nothing: Plain wrong, it shows minimum for many.
You say you have support for partner with Jxx: Wrong in the eyes of some posters.
Mayb you shoudl try to reread the posting and ask if something is not understandable.
You state that a 2 NT bid shows no extras. (I won´t subsrcirbe that this is in all 2/1 systems the case, but ok)
In this case, why do you bid 3 Diamond? 2 NT describes your hand perfectly. If pd is interessted in a diamond slam or in 5 Diamond, he can bid his suit again or he can bid 3 Club and you can show your weak support now.
The 95 % majority here does disagree with you, they just talk about 2 NT vs. 2 Spade or an artifical 2 Heart.
But maybe we are all wrong and so had been our teachers. Good luck that there are at least two who had seen the light.
P.S: there are (at least) two reasons why you shoudl reserve 3 Diamond for stronger hands with better support: 1. Your pd can judge your hand MUCH better and
2. The normal game when you have a minor fit is 3 NT, so you better search for this fiorst and for 5 Diamond later.
Roland
Sanity Check: Failure (Fluffy)
More system is not the answer...
#27
Posted 2007-October-12, 10:54
-P.J. Painter.
#28
Posted 2007-October-12, 10:58
My Q to 2 ♠ bidders.Doesn't your P ever assume that you have a 6 card ♠ suit and put you in 4 ♠ with 2 card support?
My Q to all 2/1 theorists.Isn't it possible that even after a 2/1 response sometimes it could be prudent to stop in 4 of a minor?
BTW can it be that there are 4 versions of 2/1 (at least ) and your rebid depends on which one you are playing?
Do unto others as you would have others do unto you.
"Mediocrity knows nothing higher than itself, but talent instantly recognizes genius".
#29
Posted 2007-October-12, 11:42
Quote
Allowing 3d on mins with mediocre support
-- prevents you from having 3d promise extras, hurting you on hands where opener has extras but can no longer show them below 3nt
-- hurts when responder has extras, but can't afford to bypass 3nt opposite the more common minimums.
-- combination of these two tends to lead to either missed slams or 4nt/5d -1
-- consumes space generally, as noted making it harder to clarify the stopper situation for 3nt.
On the other hand, it is rather unclear when 3d here is likely to lead to a better contract than temporizing with 2M/2nt first. Perhaps you can provide examples? 3d may make most sense to you at this point, but it's no gain for you unless you reach a better eventual contract.
#30
Posted 2007-October-12, 11:56
zasanya, on Oct 12 2007, 06:58 PM, said:
2♠ certainly cannot promise 6 here since you could have a 5♠5♣ hand too weak for 3♣. OK if 3♣ doesn't show extras then I suppose 2♠ should promise 6, but that style is rare if existent at all.
But it is possible that partner will take 2♠ followed by 3♦ as showing 6 spades and 3-4 diamonds. I suppose (I might be wrong) that this is something to discuss with p. If that is the case you probably have to rebid 2N with this hand.
Over a 2♣ response I would say that 2♠ should promise 6 in American style (not in French style) because you're allowed to rebid 2♦ on a 3-card as the most convenient bid.
#31
Posted 2007-October-12, 11:59
second choice 2nt.
Yes many play 2s promises only a minimum hand and only 5 spades but I am not convinced of the merits of that.
As usual we need to make alot of assumtions but I play all of these so:
1) This is a normal opener, I could have less.
2) 2s promises 6
3) 3D only promises 3 and does not promise extra.
4) 3H rebid by partner is assumed to be a 3nt try but it may an advanced cue if partner bids over 3nt.
It seems if you want to avoid these problems than just agree to pass balanced 12 pointers in first or second seat or agree what you will rebid here. Very common hand pattern.
#32
Posted 2007-October-12, 11:59
I've never had agreements where I'd raise 3♦ with this hand.
Harald
#33
Posted 2007-October-12, 12:02
So looks like even Fred agrees that it is a matter of style and I don't understand why people are arguing
#34
Posted 2007-October-12, 12:28
ArtK78, on Oct 12 2007, 11:39 AM, said:
Hannie, on Oct 11 2007, 11:47 PM, said:
1S - 2D
??
This was the problem hand as it was originally presented.
Does the absence of the ♥10 change your opinion any?
Yes, I bid 2♠ without it, 2NT with it. But either bid is reasonable in either case.
Quote
??? Partner will think 2♠ DENIES 6 spades? How am I even supposed to have a serious discussion here?
Quote
Qx has clear advantages in rightsiding which is part of why I like 2NT. But if you are very worried about clubs being unstopped, that is an excellent argument for 2♠. However, if you can figure out a way for opener to declare 3NT if he raises to 3♦ and responder has Axx or Kxx of clubs, I do want to hear that.
Quote
2NT has one potential flaw, which I had already mentioned. I still can see no flaw at all to 2♠, except for the possibility of wrongsiding which certainly is not an argument in favor of 3♦.
Quote
Comments like this don't really enlighten, the entire point is that no one else (sorry, go Mike777!) agrees that it shows what you have. Don't you agree that if you bid either 2♠ and 2NT first and THEN support diamonds on the next round, you are giving a more accurate depiction of your degree of support? I find that a difficult assertion to dispute, though of course people often surprise me.
#35
Posted 2007-October-12, 12:54
If I played the Bergen 12-14 NT catchall, 2NT, even tho I am not overly happy.
Otherwise, sigh, 3♦.
And from experience, there are many, many accidents from this type of sequence when pard does one action versus another in virgin 2/1 partnerships...a good problem hand here.
#36
Posted 2007-October-12, 13:03
jdonn, on Oct 12 2007, 01:28 PM, said:
Quote
??? Partner will think 2♠ DENIES 6 spades? How am I even supposed to have a serious discussion here?
I did not say that the 2♠ rebid denied 6 spades (my exact words were "Partner may assume that you do not have 6 spades..."). Only that when you play a style in which the 2♠ rebid becomes a sort of catch-all bid, partner will assume the most likely distribution - 5 cards. He will not change his assumption until you bid spades again.
That is one of the flaws with the 2♠ rebid in this style - it says nothing.
#37
Posted 2007-October-12, 13:31
1s=2d
3nt show with no special agreements or conventions?
#38
Posted 2007-October-12, 13:34
mike777, on Oct 12 2007, 11:31 AM, said:
1s=2d
3nt show with no special agreements or conventions?
Usually a 15-17 5=3=2=3 that didn't want to open 1N.
#39
Posted 2007-October-12, 16:06
ArtK78, on Oct 12 2007, 11:39 AM, said:
Hannie, on Oct 11 2007, 11:47 PM, said:
1S - 2D
??
This was the problem hand as it was originally presented.
No, it actually isn't but that is not very relevant.
ArtK78, on Oct 12 2007, 11:39 AM, said:
That is indeed the point. There are (at least) two different branches of 2/1 bidding. In one style you should show your shape regardless of whether you have extra values or not. In the other style the 2M rebid is made a catch all and all higher rebids are made more descriptive. For example, you would raise to 3D on AQxxx Jxx AQJx x but not on the given hand. The general idea of this second style is that the higher the rebid, the more descriptive it should be.
Now while it is true that the first style used to be reasonably fashionable, it seems that it has almost disappeared. I am not in a position to know for a fact that it is inferior to the second style, but that is my impression. Most of the posters who have responded here are familiar with these two styles, and seem to think that the second style is better. You are of course very welcome to defend the first style, but saying that we don't understand 2/1 bidding is uncalled for imo.
- hrothgar
#40
Posted 2007-October-12, 16:44
ArtK78, on Oct 12 2007, 02:03 PM, said:
jdonn, on Oct 12 2007, 01:28 PM, said:
Quote
??? Partner will think 2♠ DENIES 6 spades? How am I even supposed to have a serious discussion here?
I did not say that the 2♠ rebid denied 6 spades (my exact words were "Partner may assume that you do not have 6 spades..."). Only that when you play a style in which the 2♠ rebid becomes a sort of catch-all bid, partner will assume the most likely distribution - 5 cards. He will not change his assumption until you bid spades again.
That is one of the flaws with the 2♠ rebid in this style - it says nothing.
Why would partner assume anything? He will assume 5+ spades since we have shown 5+ spades. Are you seriously trying to suggest he will just bid 3NT with a doubleton spade all the time now because he is assuming we don't have 6 spades?
The fact 2♠ essentially shows nothing in this style is a benefit for every single other bid. Like when you raise partner to 3♦ tomorrow he doesn't have to worry you raised him to 3♦ on a balanced hand with Jxx of diamonds.

Help

1S - 2D
??