Posted 2004-February-18, 10:25
This is a very popular psyche, and your partner not only should have smelled a rat, he should have smelled a stinky, rancid one.
If you had values and spades, after your partner wacked 3NT, you would have wacked 4♠ yourself. Your vulnerable opponents found enough to force to game and your partner has a very nice hand for the auction. I am afraid the cat is totally out of the bag on this one. To change analogies from the rat, when you failed to pass the 1Nt-X (choosing 2♦, your cat stuck its head out of the bag. When you passed 3♠, it might not have gotten completely out, but when you passed 4♠ the cat was all over the counter top and rubbing against everyone's legs.
Next, to the question if should you run to 5♦. I think the answer is no. The reason why, your psyche is so obvious now to all... that the double is inspite of your pyche. Your partner may have some reason for the double, like (assuming 15 point NT)...
♠Qx
♥Kxx
♦Axxx
♣AJTx
And who knows, you might claw together 4 tricks, one in each suit. In fact, the problem with this psyche, you never get across to your partner that you have a five card fit for h is diamond suit, and if he is looking at 5 or 6♦ he might not get the idea that you have psyched. Over 1NT-DBL, I would have bid 3♦ rather than two to get across my legnth. With no specific agreement, your partner may play you for a rock on this auction, but if so, why jump in ♦... over the dbl, I think this should shout weakness and legnth. Now as to how many ♠, you may still have four... or maybe not. But now you have 5♦ in play as a cheap sacrafice (losing 1♠, 1♥ and 1♣.
Ben
Ben
--Ben--