Your logic is not flawed at all UDAY. The
♦Hook and
♦ elimination is the right start. Now play on trumps. From this play, you will get all the clues you need to find your (correct) play. Poor EAST has to keep three
♠ as you summize, else you can simply duck a
♠. The key ending is one like this...
West has discarded well, playing the
♦K when you ruffed one and his partner played the
♦J (play the known card..and it looks like EAST could have
♦T left for his
♦J play). But the fact that no one has pitched a
♠ still looms large. If west had 4
♠ originally (leaving him with
♠Q8x) east would have thrown a
♦ in here not all those
♣s perhaps. So if you are on your toes, you cash the last trump, discarding a
♣ from dummy. East has to let go a club, else you duck a
♠ to him to set up the long
♠, but this doesn't help. You cash the
♣A, removing his exit card, and exit with a
♠ ducked safely to EAST. This works whether WEST has a singleton
♣ or a doubleton
♣ - although EAST has to have no more than 3
♦ for this play to work. But if EAST had 5
♠ instead of 4, surely he has only 3
♦.
Very, very well done, UDAY.
Ben
1♦-1♥
3♥-4NT
5♠-5NT
6♦-6♥
Pass
T1. ♠4-9-T-A
T2. ♥7-4-Q-3
T3. ♥J-♣2-♥K-9
Can you maximize your chances and earn credit for a gold star plau?