Raising clubs with a 4-card major makes a lot of sense to me. If you start with spades, you need a way to show clubs forcingly in the next round. Playing Pavlicek's method (described here by Hannie as "New Suit Invitational") helps, but if partner raises spades on what might be a 3-card, it can become muddy.
Dutch experts Brulleman/Wijma play inverted minors raise with 4-card support and a 4-card in a major (or even both majors). But they need a GF hand to raise. I think this is related to the auction:
1m-2m
2NT-?
If responder has an invitational hand with a 4-card major, you may be playing 2NT when you have a fit in a major suit.
I suppose you could agree that an inverted minors denies a 4-card major unless you have GF values.
What to respond?
#21
Posted 2007-February-15, 18:11
The world would be such a happy place, if only everyone played Acol :) --- TramTicket
#22
Posted 2007-February-15, 19:15
FYI -- an approach that works well for this hand and that I prefer:
1♣-P-2♣ is either GF and artificial (no 5-card major), or club fit and invitational+.
Opener rebids one-under a four-card major if he has one, or 2♠ without a major, 2NT with balanced (and appropriate for range), 3♣ with a club-diamond reverse hand, 3♦/♥/♠ solo splinter, 3NT balanced higher range (usually go through 2♠).
On this one, if Opener bids 2♥ (spades), great! Bid 2♠ to agree on the 4-4 spade fit and start cuebidding.
If partner bids 2♦ (hearts), you can bid 2♠ (in case he is 44 in the majors). If he also has a spade fit, he will probably agree spades at 3♠ (or some picture jump or splinter) and you are again cuebidding.
If partner bids 2♠ or 2NT, 3♣ by you would be invitational only. So, you can bid 3♥, agreeing clubs as the focus, GF, isolating a diamond hole, and either NT probe or slam probe.
If partner bids 3♣+, you are off to a grand most likely.
1♣-P-2♣ is either GF and artificial (no 5-card major), or club fit and invitational+.
Opener rebids one-under a four-card major if he has one, or 2♠ without a major, 2NT with balanced (and appropriate for range), 3♣ with a club-diamond reverse hand, 3♦/♥/♠ solo splinter, 3NT balanced higher range (usually go through 2♠).
On this one, if Opener bids 2♥ (spades), great! Bid 2♠ to agree on the 4-4 spade fit and start cuebidding.
If partner bids 2♦ (hearts), you can bid 2♠ (in case he is 44 in the majors). If he also has a spade fit, he will probably agree spades at 3♠ (or some picture jump or splinter) and you are again cuebidding.
If partner bids 2♠ or 2NT, 3♣ by you would be invitational only. So, you can bid 3♥, agreeing clubs as the focus, GF, isolating a diamond hole, and either NT probe or slam probe.
If partner bids 3♣+, you are off to a grand most likely.
"Gibberish in, gibberish out. A trial judge, three sets of lawyers, and now three appellate judges cannot agree on what this law means. And we ask police officers, prosecutors, defense lawyers, and citizens to enforce or abide by it? The legislature continues to write unreadable statutes. Gibberish should not be enforced as law."
-P.J. Painter.
-P.J. Painter.

Help
