[jillybean]

..

---

1st seat, teams, both vulnerable.

There's probably not a perfect answer but let's hear yours.

[WasWinM]

I never played Acol but I did read tons of Terrence Reese so I think in Reese-style Acol he would have opened this 2H. In this new world, I open 1H.

[apollo1201]

1st thought is wow great hand.

2nd thought is who the hell is the bast*** who stole a card from my hand.

After finding out and reclaiming what is mine, depending on whether I found a small non H, a small H or a big interesting card (A or Q S, Q H, A D or K C), my 1st call will be different.

[Cyberyeti]

jillybean, on 2026-November-04, 08:39, said:

..

---

1st seat, teams, both vulnerable.

There's probably not a perfect answer but let's hear yours.

Call the director and get another card - perfect answer

[mikeh]

1H. This is not going to go all pass and all actions by the other three players will tell me something that I expect will help.

[mw64ahw]

1♥ or 4♣ Namyats depending on the 13th card.

[pescetom]

There are not many cards you could add to this hand to sway me from 1♥.

[jillybean]

Perfect day, not so perfect eyesight.
I think I counted the hearts as an 8 bagger A K J 1 0 9 8 5

---

[apollo1201]

Ok so it corresponds as an Acol 2 (7 cards. 8-8.5 playing tricks) which I can express (2C 2D 3H, with 2C strong but not GF in my country), although at quite a high level.

1H is a definite possibility as well and it could place us better to learn about partner and opps cards (although we probably need to jump to 3C or bid 2S next when partner does not pass, the latter risking partner chase us correcting H to S), and I would chose this absent this strong but not GF option.

A GF call would clearly be an overbid.

[Cyberyeti]

1♥ unless you're playing a strong club or Acol 2♥ I don't see any alternative, yes you're making game opposite Qxx, xxx, xxx, xxxx, but a GF bid is too much

[jillybean]

My table.

---

OT

---

It was a shocker, -10. C'est la vie. I am happy with my opening.

[mikeh]

That’s quite a remarkable pass by east! I wonder: did south take longer than usual to bid?

[jillybean]

mikeh, on 2026-November-05, 07:22, said:

That’s quite a remarkable pass by east! I wonder: did south take longer than usual to bid?

I did not, my tempo is impeccable.

[kgr]

I would open 2♣ with that hand. SF for me (2♦ GF). If I have only 2♣ GF then still 2♣. I prefer to open strong when I have enough points (17+) and partner needs only a Q to give game a good chance.

[mw64ahw]

Namyats for me
Minor suit preempt 3N
3♠ Gambling 3NT
etc.

[jillybean]

Congratulations to everyone on finding the perfect auction using the 'Peek-a-Boo' convention.

[mw64ahw]

mikeh, on 2026-November-05, 07:22, said:

That’s quite a remarkable pass by east! I wonder: did south take longer than usual to bid?

East must be one of those players who will only double with 12hcp and overcall with 11hcp

[Cyberyeti]

mikeh, on 2026-November-05, 07:22, said:

That’s quite a remarkable pass by east! I wonder: did south take longer than usual to bid?

Did N take longer than normal to pass ?

[Cyberyeti]

I would not pass with the N hand, respond an "Acol" NF 1N (and I might double that with the E hand)

[pescetom]

jillybean, on 2026-November-04, 16:32, said:

Perfect day, not so perfect eyesight.
I think I counted the hearts as an 8 bagger A K J 1 0 9 8 5

You were probably playing on BBO, which for no good reason displays T as 1 0 (and kerns an oversize Q to boot).
The obvious fix has been repeatedly suggested for over T years now.