[EugeneLS]

For the record: I'm all in favour of Kibbing; I do it myself and it certainly gets a lot of mention in Victor Mollo's immortal Menagerie series!

Kibbing is allowed in the 'social' clubs and I notice that Kibbers are allowed to post comments 'to the table' so that they can be seen by players.

Of course I'm sure that 99% of those who Kibitz on BBO play by the rules, and don't post comments that could influence the play.

Unfortunately the remaining 1% aren't so well-intentioned. For this reason many BBO'ers when starting a table go for the "no kibitzing" option. I think this is a shame: it limits the choice of tables we can watch. Could something be done about it - apart from using the "permission to Kibitz" option?

[mike777]

EugeneLS, on 2026-October-25, 06:10, said:

For the record: I'm all in favour of Kibbing; I do it myself and it certainly gets a lot of mention in Victor Mollo's immortal Menagerie series!

Kibbing is allowed in the 'social' clubs and I notice that Kibbers are allowed to post comments 'to the table' so that they can be seen by players.

Of course I'm sure that 99% of those who Kibitz on BBO play by the rules, and don't post comments that could influence the play.

Unfortunately the remaining 1% aren't so well-intentioned. For this reason many BBO'ers when starting a table go for the "no kibitzing" option. I think this is a shame: it limits the choice of tables we can watch. Could something be done about it - apart from using the "permission to Kibitz" option?

You have the option of allowing kibitzing and denying them from talking to the table.
Probably more than 1% just prefer their game to be private.

[jillybean]

The table host needs the ability to remove a kibitzer, like we have now to remove a player.

I experienced this problem recently.
It’s a situation where there is a group of players who play together regularly so kibitzing and chat to table is appreciated.
One random kibitzer made some misguided comments to the table.

The comments may have been intended for the kibitzers, it’s happened to me before.
What is the default destination for chat messages when kibitzing ?

[EugeneLS]

jillybean, on 2026-October-25, 08:56, said:

What is the default destination for chat messages when kibitzing ?

The default is 'chat to [other] kibbers'. Obviously not much fun if you're the only one!

Recently I was kibbing - quite innocently, just watching - and a player complained that a kibitzer (obviously not me) had made insulting remarks. I don't know whether it was to the table or privately to one of the players.

Suggestions as to the bidding or play, after a hand has been played out: fine if made politely. Otherwise - keep stumm!