Posted Yesterday, 23:49
It’s possible but unlikely that partner has three hearts…normally one expects 5=5 minors so he’d need to be 0=3=5=5 which is possible but how would he bid with x xxx AKQx QJ10xx. I’m not advocating for 3C with that hand but it’s not as if te other possible call of 2N is a great bargain. 2H said nothing about responders hand other than that he has 4+ spades and gf values.
So I’d resolve the immediate problem over 3c by bidding 3H. I’m pulling 3N, if he felt it the best bid…not on this hand of course…to 4C which shows my exact shape.
Opener bids 3S…he’s already denied three spades so this is easy. Now responder has a problem. He expects 2=1=5=5 almost all the time and it’s not clear that 5C is fit showing…I’d expect it was cuebid. Exclusion (5D) would create an unusual situation: one which I’ve never seen nor heard of before. How does, if at all, the responder to exclusion show a different void?
Anyway, maybe responder argues that opener is unlikely to be, say, xx x AKQJx QJxxx and all he needs for slam to be good is Ax and the club queen so it’s worth pushing
Am I claiming I’d think that way at the table ? There’s no way I can know.
'one of the great markers of the advance of human kindness is the howls you will hear from the Men of God' Johann Hari