[cencio]

---

[mw64ahw]

Assuming you're playing 5-card Majors 2/1 GF or GI it's a clear 2♣ bid.
What you do after that depends on your continuations, but I'm not discounting playing in a Spade slam rather than a Club one.

[paulg]

mw64ahw, on 2026-April-12, 04:26, said:

Assuming you're playing 5-card Majors 2/1 GF or GI it's a clear 2♣ bid.
What you do after that depends on your continuations, but I'm not discounting playing in a Spade slam rather than a Club one.

I agree it is a clear 2♣ overcall and continuations will depend on what happens next. A spade slam is unlikely in my view.

[pescetom]

 mw64ahw, on 2026-April-12, 04:26, said:

Assuming you're playing 5-card Majors 2/1 GF or GI it's a clear 2♣ bid.
What you do after that depends on your continuations, but I'm not discounting playing in a Spade slam rather than a Club one.

I suspect you misread the diagram and thought you were responding.

For me a 2♣ overcall.

[mw64ahw]

pescetom, on 2026-April-12, 05:40, said:

I suspect you misread the diagram and thought you were responding.

For me a 2♣ overcall.

Yep absent the ?, but 2♣ as an overall happy to rebid.

[jillybean]

I think many will believe South must start with a X and then bid clubs.
This is a direct 2♣ overcall for me, partner will cooperate or I will rebid clubs.

I am not ready to call this 8 card suit "trump"

[P_Marlowe]

Hi,

It is a tactical decision.
You can start with X followed by bidding clubs, or bid 2C and repeat clubs.
I would go with 2C, the followup seq. appear to be simpler.
The adv. of X is, that in case p makes a pos. move and you can blast 5C.

In the end this is a hand, that will force you at one point to make a decision,
you can try to gather information on how high you are willing to go.

Scoring matters.

With kind regards
Marlowe

[pescetom]

P_Marlowe, on 2026-April-12, 10:41, said:

It is a tactical decision.
You can start with X followed by bidding clubs, or bid 2C and repeat clubs.
I would go with 2C, the followup seq. appear to be simpler.
The adv. of X is, that in case p makes a pos. move and you can blast 5C.

In the end this is a hand, that will force you at one point to make a decision,
you can try to gather information on how high you are willing to go.

Scoring matters.

Now that the pendulum has swung to an overcall with up to 18 HCP the question becomes what X and then suit should promise (and even whether it should remain NF when below game).
Holding a long major, I tend to reserve the X and then suit for a hand rich in values but unpromising for slam.
Holding a long minor I tend towards an overcall, it's not obvious to me on which hands X then suit will likely be a winner.

[mikeh]

Now that the pendulum has swung made me laugh. I’m not sure when this phenomenon is thought to have happened but some leading theorists (anyone remember the late, great Eric Kokish?) advocated for virtually unlimited overcall more than 30 years ago

To me, the key to deciding double or double befall depends more on shape than hcp. In particular I strain to avoid a takeout double of a major when I can’t stand partner bidding to a high level in the other major

If I were to double, I have to anticipate plausible sequences. How about (1S) x (3S) 4H?

Do I really want to bid 5C here? I think not.

I’ve overcalled, with nothing bad happening, on far stronger hands than an 18 count. For me double then suit suggests a good 17 with a good suit and the ability to handle most and preferably all likely continuations around the table.