[pigpenz]

♠8
♥Q
♦KQJ975432
♣43

the auction was short and simple 2NT pass 3NT all pass
I dont know how Gib evaluates after all these years but this was bizarro

[pescetom]

Bizzarro.
But hey, with 8 points he could hardly pass

[FelicityR]

Just when you needed Gerber...yes, that old-fangled gadget for checking aces.

[pescetom]

 FelicityR, on 2020-January-18, 22:19, said:

Just when you needed Gerber...yes, that old-fangled gadget for checking aces.

looks like an example constructed to prove its worth

But if you play 3S as a gadget for minors then you should be able to keycard in clubs, which would be even better here (although if he happens to have only 2 which is just possible with our 2nt then you are going to look silly).

[pigpenz]

ran this one through the simulator
defintely one to be playing something like walsh transfers....3♠ relay to 3nt then describe hand afterwards
but contract definetly should be played by 2NT hand to protect a King on lead.....% wise best contract is 5♦

[pescetom]

 pigpenz, on 2020-January-19, 12:26, said:

% wise best contract is 5♦

Sounds odd to me.
Actual numbers?
How did you define 2NT?

[zhasbeen]

I'm curious as to why none of you play in ACBL Daylong games. Seems like a knowledgeable group.





































s

[karen_nyc]

I had a similar issue recently. I opened 2NT and robot partner held QJTxxxxx and absolutely no entries. It might have been all right if I'd held xxx, but I held AK tight. 5C was cold but 3N went down. The robots don't seem to be programmed to understand the value of playing in a really long suit when it's a minor.