2H is completely right. I play that a raise to 3C shows a better hand than this. Either a stronger hand generally or better club support. Taking a delayed raise to 3C is a much better way of doing it.
In addition, I play that 1S 2C 2H 3C is still 100% GF. But then I still play old-school style invitational jump shifts.
If opener holds:
Ax
Qxx
Qxx
AKJxx
he shouldn't jump to 3NT after 2H. A simple (forcing) 2NT is ample here. 1) Opener could be 5-5 in the majors, in which case 4H looks best, 2) partner could hold Qxx in clubs, in which case 6 C looks best, 3) partner might have a 6th spade, in which case 4S looks best. The whole idea behind playing 2/1 GF is not to jump to 3NT unless you're certain it's the best contract. With this hand, auction should go:
1S 2C
2H 2NT
3C 3S
4D 5C, might try 4S at matchpoints.
What do you bid? Is it now or never?
#22
Posted 2005-April-20, 02:16
2♥ obvious for me too and for all the reasons the others have already explained !
Alain
Alain
Alain
#23
Posted 2005-April-20, 06:00
3♣ is not even an option, I need 4 cards to raise partner's minor, wouldn't raise even with ♣AKQ
#24
Posted 2005-April-20, 13:55
Trixie is confused by this question and some of the responses to it. She does not even know anyone (except her first husband Elmer, and he couldn't play a lick) who would bid 3C playing any system at any form of scoring. My goodness, you don't even have a club honor.
Trixi
#25
Posted 2005-April-20, 14:06
no question, 2H. Don't raise responder's 2/1 minor with 3-card support unless you have no alternative. The 3C shows 4-card support.
Change the hand to KQxxx x AKJx xxx and I rebid 2D.
Change the hand to KQxxx x AKJx xxx and I rebid 2D.

Help
