[lycier]

---

1- Gib N should overcall 2♦ instead of balancing overcall.
2- Strangely, my double says " 1♥,10+hcp,biddable ♦,10-TPs".
I think it is impossible :
If only singleton of ♥,I should respond 1nt,never raise to 2♥.
If I have 10+hcp with 3-card ♥,I should respond 2♣ - Drury while Gib W opens 1♥ in the 3rd seat.
So the correct explanations of my double is "3-4♥,10-hcp,biddable ♦,10-TPs".

P.S.
Please refer to others's hands in the same time.

Hand-A

---

Hand-B

---

Hand-C

---

Hand-D

---

Hand-E

---

Hand-F

---

Hand-G

---

Now we can draw the following conclusions:
1- Almost of Gibs made balancing overcall except Hand-G.And Gib never overcall 2♦,why?
2- After 3♦,Gib never make penalty double,why?
3-Why did Gib N make passing bid instead of balancing overcall in the Hand-G ? Only exception.

[Bbradley62]

See the responses in the many other threads in which you asked why GIB doesn't behave consistently at different tables in MBC.

[Bbradley62]

But, the explanation of the pass is bizarre. Doesn't P-1♥-2♥-P mean the same thing as 1♥-2♥-P? The explanation shouldn't say anything about "third hand", and it doesn't deserve an explanation in one sequence if it doesn't get one in the other.

[Bbradley62]

It's also weird that this was so frequently hand 6.

[1eyedjack]

lycier, on 2015-March-27, 05:33, said:

1- Gib N should overcall 2♦ instead of balancing overcall.

With this I disagree.

[iandayre]

1eyedjack, on 2015-March-27, 22:40, said:

With this I disagree.

While I certainly see your point, with favorable vulnerability and given that 2D takes up maximum room over the 1H opener, I would overcall.