Open or not? Opening in 3rd seat
#1
Posted 2005-February-28, 17:01
Hand 1 - Non-vul vs. vul
♠AJ4 - ♥T94 - ♦QT875 - ♣A8
Hand 2 - Both vul
♠J7 - ♥952 - ♦AKQJ3 - ♣653
#2
Posted 2005-February-28, 17:06
#3
Posted 2005-February-28, 17:25
Fred Gitelman
Bridge Base Inc.
www.bridgebase.com
#4
Posted 2005-February-28, 17:25
#5
Posted 2005-February-28, 17:36
i would pass both hands, tho if i opened either it would be 1nt on hand 1...
#6
Posted 2005-February-28, 17:58
#7 Guest_Jlall_*
Posted 2005-February-28, 22:17
#8
Posted 2005-February-28, 23:24
#9
Posted 2005-March-01, 00:23
Open second with 2D in third seat if we play that as weak and both not vul, open 3D in first or third seat if not vul and opponents vul. Pass other seats and vulnerabilities
Ben
#11
Posted 2005-March-01, 02:44
2. I open 2D or 3D, as above
#12
Posted 2005-March-01, 03:20
I have a defensive hand so I want to defend. I don't want to help them place the cards if they do end up in a contract. The bid is not very pre-emptive. It is not particularly lead-directing. If I open hands like this it makes it harder for partner when I have a genuine opening bid in this position (I realise that for Ben this is a genuine opening bid!).
It may be because of the level of opponents I generally play against, but if I open this sort of hand, then either we end up playing for a minus score or the opponents end up at a lower, safer level than they would if I had passed (because they are more scared of the -200 if they think I have some points). Whereas passing often leads to a nice +100 when opponents bid slightly too high or misplay because they don't expect me to have quite so much.
So what is your reasoning for opening this hand?
Eric
#13
Posted 2005-March-01, 03:28
NV, I play weak NT so 1NT !
2nd :
Only open if i have the 2♦ bid as a weak 2 ! As I don't have it I would pass.
#14
Posted 2005-March-01, 04:16
EricK, on Mar 1 2005, 10:20 AM, said:
I have a defensive hand so I want to defend. I don't want to help them place the cards if they do end up in a contract. The bid is not very pre-emptive. It is not particularly lead-directing. If I open hands like this it makes it harder for partner when I have a genuine opening bid in this position (I realise that for Ben this is a genuine opening bid!).
It may be because of the level of opponents I generally play against, but if I open this sort of hand, then either we end up playing for a minus score or the opponents end up at a lower, safer level than they would if I had passed (because they are more scared of the -200 if they think I have some points). Whereas passing often leads to a nice +100 when opponents bid slightly too high or misplay because they don't expect me to have quite so much.
So what is your reasoning for opening this hand?
Eric
If you open the 1st hand 1D, you can compete up to 2M when pard has a 5-card major and a few points. If you pass, that can be more difficult to evaluate:
pass pass pass 1H ..? <--- will pard bid 1S on Txxxx Kxx Ax xxx?
Maybe he ends up bidding 1S, but it would be much easier if it had gone
pass pass 1D 1H
1S
Opening 2D has a different objective: lure opps into bidding a losing 3/4M. The 2D is unilateral, meaning you WILL lose a major suit 5-3 fit. By opening 2D you're gambling opps will be more eager to (mis)bid than to pass.
#15
Posted 2005-March-01, 04:46
EricK, on Mar 1 2005, 04:20 AM, said:
I have a defensive hand so I want to defend. I don't want to help them place the cards if they do end up in a contract. The bid is not very pre-emptive. It is not particularly lead-directing. If I open hands like this it makes it harder for partner when I have a genuine opening bid in this position (I realise that for Ben this is a genuine opening bid!).
It may be because of the level of opponents I generally play against, but if I open this sort of hand, then either we end up playing for a minus score or the opponents end up at a lower, safer level than they would if I had passed (because they are more scared of the -200 if they think I have some points). Whereas passing often leads to a nice +100 when opponents bid slightly too high or misplay because they don't expect me to have quite so much.
So what is your reasoning for opening this hand?
Eric
Its simple , much simple then you think, add a J to the hand, now do you open ? I hear yes, now what about all the arguments that you have given against opening, is one J change them all ?
This isnt a tactical opening, the hand just worth an opening value, 2 aces, 2 10s and good intermidiates make it worth more then the avarage 12 hcp hand.
#16
Posted 2005-March-01, 04:59
#17
Posted 2005-March-01, 05:22
EricK, on Mar 1 2005, 09:20 AM, said:
For me the reason is easy. My partner expects me to open all balanced hands with 12 hcp, and I am convinced this is one.
So for me opening is "easy bridge" and passing would be second-guessing the auction (apart from irritating partner about my opening style).
Btw, do you plan to pass throughout? If I pass now and bid later, partner has a good chance to misjudge if he has to make a decision later.
#18
Posted 2005-March-01, 06:09
2D on second hand (Actually 2C being stong or weak 2D). Not enough defence to open 1D in 3rd hand.
#19
Posted 2005-March-01, 06:13
It has a slight preemptive effect. If partner can bid 1NT it's fine, matchpoints and nonvulnerable.
As for hand 2, 2♦ is wtp. I hope that opening is available, I think it should in 3rd seat even if you prefer some other preempt structure in first and 2nd seat. Otherwise, I would pass. 3♦ is too much vulnerable.
#20 Guest_Jlall_*
Posted 2005-March-01, 11:52
EricK, on Mar 1 2005, 04:20 AM, said:
The point is describing ones hand. I never think about what might or might not happen when im choosing to open (other than my first rebid), I think is my hand worth an opener. To me this hand is worth an opener, so I will open. Good honor location, spots, enough defense, a decent 5 card suit.

Help