how to show this monster and should you push on
#1
Posted 2005-February-19, 00:06
Partner deals and opens 1d
You hold
♠A5 ♥AkQJ85 ♣A874 ♦9
I don't think I did a good job of getting the point across:
1♦ 2♣ 2♦ 3♥ 3NT 4♠ 4NT ...
From here I would probably have said 5h. Should I just go to 6?
#3
Posted 2005-February-19, 00:31
bestguru, on Feb 19 2005, 01:06 AM, said:
This is obviously a hand best suited for a strong jump shift (2♥ followed by 3♥ will set the suit), but it's not impossible to bid the hand even if you agreed on WJS.
For a start, bid your suits in the right order. Playing 2/1 some think that the correct response with the hand is 2♣ in order to establish a game force. It's not! 1♥ is as much forcing as 2♣ is (although not game forcing - yet).
I can't know how the bidding will proceed after 1♦-1♥, but let's assume opener rebids 1♠. You now venture 4th suit (2♣) and later rebid hearts which is at least slam invitational with a good 6-card suit. Then you are on the right track.
If opener rebids 2♦, I will improvise with 2♠ rather than 3♣ for 2 reasons:
1. It gives us more room.
2. Partner will not support spades, since he already denied 4 by rebidding 2♦.
Whether opener's next call is 2NT or 3♦, I will proceed with 3♥. Again at least slam invitational with own suit.
Finally, if opener rebids 1NT, I will use my 2-way check back Stayman tool (2♦ as a game forcing relay, asking for cheapest information not yet given). In a second I will rebid hearts to show exactly the same as in the two examples above.
Roland
P.S. If you play WJS you can jump to 3♥ as a game force, since 2♥ will be invitational.
#4
Posted 2005-February-19, 02:22
So:
1♦ - 1♥
1♠/1NT/2♣/2♦ - ?
jumping to 3♥ must be a strong hand now.
If partner did not bid 2♣ you can jump to 3♣ this should show at least 6♥/4♣ and strength.
If Partner bid 2♣ you might try to aim a slam in ♣.
#5
Posted 2005-February-19, 04:13
hotShot, on Feb 19 2005, 03:22 AM, said:
1♦ - 1♥
1♠/1NT/2♣/2♦ - ?
jumping to 3♥ must be a strong hand now.
In my book it shows 10-12 hcp and a 6-card suit and therefore non forcing. A good rule as to responder's rebid is: A suit at the 3-level, already bid by one of us, is always 10-12. Easy to remember.
After:
1♦-1♥
1NT
it doesn't even exist, but you could conceivably play it as above.
If you you want a jump rebid of own suit by responder to be GF, you will have a serious problem with a game invitational hand. Unless you play WJS of course; then 2♥ is invitational and 3♥ game forcing.
Roland
#6
Posted 2005-February-19, 06:35
walddk, on Feb 19 2005,, said:
I like easy to remember rules
walddk, on Feb 19 2005,, said:
Nice that you agree.
hotShot
#7
Posted 2005-February-19, 12:24
If you find this too hard to remember than you can play this as 10-12, but in that case you are probably not playing 2-way checkback anyway.
I play 1D-3H as a splinter. I wouldn't bid 3H with a casual partner on this hand unless discussed!
- hrothgar
#8
Posted 2005-February-19, 15:17
Now everyone can teach you their pet toys of checkback, 2 way checkback, xyz, NMF, splinters, REVERSES ON 2 AND 3 CARD SUITS, etc etc etc etc to fix all the problems of 2/1.
You may wish to learn to COUNT and VISUALIZE hands and learn to bid lONGEST suits first before embarking on this Wierd Wild Journey.
#9
Posted 2005-February-19, 21:50
Walddk: I appreciate the breakdown and most of what you say there makes sense. I'd be worried about the 2♠ over 2♦ since it distorts the shape of your hand. Is this risky when you are pretty sure you are going to press for a small slam? You can always show your spade control later.
Mike: Good advice about COUNT and VISUALIZATION. I'm working on them. Still bends my mind most hands. As for bidding longest suits first, I'd really like to avoid that
#10
Posted 2005-February-20, 02:18
bestguru, on Feb 19 2005, 10:50 PM, said:
2♠ would not be control showing, merely one way of making opener bid again (new suit by an unpassed responder is always forcing). So would 3♣ be of course, but 2♠ gives us a little more room (opener can bid 2NT), and he/she will not support spades, because he/she doesn't have 4.
Distorting the shape of my hand you may claim. Yes, but that is not an issue here. I am the captain, because opener has shown a limited hand by rebidding 2♦. My aim is to set hearts and learn about opener's controls later.
This is a formulation of the issue:
We play strong jump shifts:
Bid 2♥ on your first turn, and bid 3♥ next. That will set the suit and ask opener to cue bid. He/she may bid 4♥ as the weakest bid possible with a hand unsuitable for slam (lack of controls).
We play weak jump shifts:
Bid 1♥ and rebid 3♥. This is game forcing with a strongish 6+ card suit, because a direct 2♥ would be weak, and 1♥ followed by 2♥ invitational. If opener's rebid is 1NT, however, a special agreement applies if you play some kind of check back Stayman.
Roland

Help
