How to bid 7H! 2/1 bidding problem
#1
Posted 2013-December-29, 20:26
Partner opened 1h and RHO overcalled 2d.
This is the auction.
W N E S
1H 2D 3D*
P 3S* P 4D*
P 4NT* P 5C*
P 5D* P 5S*
P 6H AP
3D = H fit, limit raise+
3S/4D = Cuebid
4N = RKC, 5C = 1/4
5D = inquery for q
5S = HQ + SK
After 3S, we bid 3nt as serious slam interest.
Partner holds AXX KJXXX QJ9 AK. Would you please give me some comments about the auction,
and which is your suggesting auction. Thanks again.
#3
Posted 2013-December-29, 22:41
Depending on your requirements for a limit raise (and there is a reasonable argument that your hand is worth one even without the heart Q), partner might be able to guess to bid the grand at that point, especially if playing MPs in a strong field where 52% grand slams are at worst slightly against the odds.
#5
Posted 2013-December-29, 23:38
Responder would have bid the same way with Kxx QXXX AX QXXX or with KXX AQXX KX JXXX.
Showing a useful void in response to RKC might have succeeded, but discussion about follow-ups after that jump bid showing one Key and the void would still be necessary.
Starting with a Splinter 4D Response seems obvious, rather than a non-descript 3D Lr+ bid. But, it would lead to the same problem if you don't show all the controls.
#6
Posted 2013-December-30, 01:48
#7
Posted 2013-December-30, 04:30
#8
Posted 2013-December-30, 06:24
#9
Posted 2013-December-30, 19:11
or partner needs you to have 6♣ to throw ♠ loser
I don't see how one partner can show this to other if u start with 4♦
#10
Posted 2013-December-30, 19:23
Not sure pard will know to bid 7h after showing one keycard and d void with 6d.wont know about HQ.
#11
Posted 2013-December-30, 20:13
steve2005, on 2013-December-30, 19:11, said:
or partner needs you to have 6♣ to throw ♠ loser
I don't see how one partner can show this to other if u start with 4♦
Only needs 6 clubs if the clubs are bad, Kxxx, AQxx, void Qxxxx seems to be pretty good.
We are helped by 4♦ being specifically a void for us.
1♥-(2♦)-4♦
4♠(KC)-5♣(1/4)
5♦(Q♥?)-5♠(yes + K♠)
6♣-7♥
The worst this can be on is AKx/J109xxx to come in, and if partner has 2 or 4 clubs it's a lot better than that.
#12
Posted 2014-January-08, 11:54
1♥ - (2♦) - 4♦;
4♠ - 6♦;
7♥
So I do not see the lack of CY's void splinter agreement as a major impediment here.
#14
Posted 2014-January-09, 03:11
Lorne50, on 2013-December-30, 06:24, said:
I think in the given seq. 4D should show a shortage.
The difference between 3D / 4D and a direct 4D bid being, that the given route sets up a
forcing sequence, while a direct 4D bid does not.
Uwe Gebhardt (P_Marlowe)
#15
Posted 2014-January-09, 06:26
Our style:
4♦ at that level (below game in our suit) shows a ♦ *control* not necessarily first round control. You would want to make the same bid with KQx AQx x J10xxxx else partner will always think you are off 2 cashing ♦ tricks. RKC will then sort out the aces/voids.
Given that, you absolutely *must* show the void when partner bids 4NT else he will think you are off a cashing Ace. Then, partner may or may not get it right, but at least he has a chance. As the above posters have said, it's hard for either side to be sure the clubs will provide 13 tricks...
Splinters sort of solve this, sort of not, as you could easily have a similar hand with 3 trumps:
KQx AQx - J10xxxxx
or
KQx AQx x J10xxxx
or
KQx AQx xx J10xxx
None of the above really qualify for a splinter. With the first two, though, you need to cue 4♦, with the third your lack of cue is just as critical.
Sometimes I use big words I don't fully understand to make myself seem more photosynthesis.
#16
Posted 2014-January-09, 12:33
After the 6 diamond bid, its up to W to evaluate his hand. With the way E bid his hand, he can suspect a 6 card club suit. (With a 4-4-0-5 and a bad suit he would start 4D). This leaves him with 6 clubs. If he has a singleton spade. Then he is something like x-AQx-AKx-xxxxxx, (The 6D bid should show a well controled diamond suit, void or AK). 1-3-4-5 shape, is not real. Else he hase Kxx-AQx-A-xxxxxx, or Kxx-AQxx- -xxxxxx. With the last hand we can make 7. With the other we have good chances as well, with good breaks, although with the first of the last two hands he would not bid 6D(I think).
With your action, i do not like W bidding, due to the fact, i like opening 1NT with 5332 hands, and blackwood is not my favorite convetion(I think the blackwood is bad with his hand anyway). With his hand, all he needs from you is a spade control(King/Singleton) and 4 hearts with one Ace. If he bids 5 clubs, and you bid 5 diamonds. Then with 5NT(Grand slam try), he might hit the grand again, knowing that you need to have some values for your bidding.