Push or not?
#1
Posted 2010-April-29, 16:50
Partner deals and passes, RHO opens 1♠ (playing Precision and thus limited to 11-15). You bid 2♥, LHO jumps to 4♠ (wide-ranging of course), and partner after a bit of thought finds 5♥. Pass, pass, LHO raises to 5♠, pass, pass, back to you.
-- Bertrand Russell
#2
Posted 2010-April-29, 16:54
"100% certain that many excellent players would disagree. This is far more about style/judgment than right vs. wrong." Fred
"Hysterical Raisins again - this time on the World stage, not just the ACBL" mycroft
#3
Posted 2010-April-29, 17:11
Please don't tell us how much partner thought before, it is inappropriate.
George Carlin
#4
Posted 2010-April-29, 17:14
gwnn, on Apr 30 2010, 12:11 AM, said:
To make, or to stop them from finding 6♠?
-- Bertrand Russell
#5
Posted 2010-April-29, 17:20
#6
Posted 2010-April-29, 17:26
jdonn, on Apr 30 2010, 12:20 AM, said:
I'd like to add that it wasn't a real hesitation - if LHO had kept the stop card out as long as she is supposed to it wouldn't have been noticable. Maybe gwnn is right and I shouldn't have mentioned it.
-- Bertrand Russell
#7
Posted 2010-April-29, 17:31
mgoetze, on Apr 29 2010, 11:14 PM, said:
gwnn, on Apr 30 2010, 12:11 AM, said:
To make, or to stop them from finding 6♠?
I don't think they make 6S. I am not sure how many hearts we can make but 6 should make enough times and opps are welcome to bid 1 more if we wouldn't have made.
George Carlin
#8
Posted 2010-April-29, 17:37
-- Bertrand Russell
#9
Posted 2010-April-29, 17:53
In fact if he has xxx xxxx - xxxxxx you make 7 on a good day...
#11
Posted 2010-April-30, 02:08
I bid 6♥, doubled by righty, and on the ♠ lead, dummy came down with ♠Qxx ♥Txxx ♦Qx ♣QTxx. I ruffed. crossed to ♣Q and ran the ♥6 for -1.
It turns out LHO had a heart void and RHO a singleton club, so that 6♠ was makeable with an antipercentage play in diamonds. Teammates were allowed to play 5♠=, 11 IMPs for us.
-- Bertrand Russell
#12
Posted 2010-April-30, 02:40
#13
Posted 2010-April-30, 02:42
jdonn and gwnn would have bid
1S-2H-4S-5H
p-6H
George Carlin
#14
Posted 2010-April-30, 02:56
gwnn, on Apr 30 2010, 10:42 AM, said:
jdonn and gwnn would have bid
1S-2H-4S-5H
p-6H
Ok, 6♥ last round was some kind of joke then.
#15
Posted 2010-April-30, 03:18
Suppose I give you 4 letters
a
b
c
d
the first letter is a
the last letter is d
In our case, we were given the auction
1S-2H-4S-5H
p-p-5S-p
p-?
Now we have three rounds of bidding basically.
the first
the second
the third
Last round is not considered to be the third since it has not really passed. Instead we exclude the rounds that have not passed and are left with twoooooo:
The first (where we bid 2H)
the second (where we passed)
The first round is conventionally known as the first round or as you quite accurately referred to it as "started with".
The second round in this case is known as the last round.
This is natural English language usage, universal, they use it in South Africa, Canada, New Zealand, Wales, Connecticut, we do not to prealert it, it is not a joke, you can Google it.
Other instances of this extremely weird concept:
"last week"=18-24 April 2010, not the seven days God created the world
"last century"=1900-2000 (roughly), not 1-100.
"Liverpool scored in the last minute"=in the stoppage time, not right after kick-off.
George Carlin
#16
Posted 2010-April-30, 03:51
gwnn, on Apr 30 2010, 11:18 AM, said:
p-p-5S-p
p-?
Thanks for the explanation, but the above would have been enough
The bidding explanation in the OP is ok, but I think the following should always be added for clarity:
(1♠)-2♥-(4♠)-5♥
(Pass)-Pass-(5♠)-Pass
(Pass)-??
#17
Posted 2010-April-30, 05:56

Help
