[rogerclee]

r/r imps

9xxx Axx Ax Axxx

P P 1C 1N
X 2D P 2H
P P ?

2D = xfer

Theoretically I think doubling 2D should just say you had a real opener, but you weren't playing that. Also your opps don't play 2-suited runouts or anything.

edit: fixed everything

[nick_s]

Something's not right here.
...
Edit: Fixed now, thanks.

[Jlall]

nick_s, on Dec 24 2009, 04:39 PM, said:

Something's not right here.
You overcalled 1N with a 4=3=3=4 12 count?

You opened 1C. He says 2D is a transfer, so obviously he just added in a pass after the double. I think it is:

p p 1C 1N
X 2D p 2H
p p ?

I still don't know what the shape is as the hand has 14 cards though.

[Fluffy]

We have a good opening hand given that strenght is behind, if partner wasn't unpassed hand I would bid 2♠ for sure.

Partner being a passed hand makes pass a strong alternative, probably the best one.

Now sure how good 3 aces is with the strenght behind, it wouldn't surprise me if random 10 counts from partner with 4 spades made 10 tricks 70% of the time.

But I am just passing

[Jlall]

Pass seems auto to me.

[pooltuna]

Jlall, on Dec 24 2009, 10:00 PM, said:

Pass seems auto to me.

yeah, its not like we're missing a game so why give them one if they make.