[shanbari]

both white

Scoring: IMP

1C (2H !) ??

what south bid ? thanks

---

[jdonn]

It's not certain partner is short (0 or 1) in hearts, but it's extremely likely, and IF he is short in hearts then he must have 5 or more clubs. Therefore I would rather search for a club contract than defend, so I'll bid 3♥. I can not bid 3♣ as I play that to be a far weaker hand than this (ace of hearts less would be about average for me.)

[han]

I like the defensive prospects in hearts with a forcing defense. Game isn't certain (This hand is not good for 3NT and we need a suitable hand from partner to make 5C) so any plus in 2HX may be good. Partner will not pass out 2H with shortness so I think it is safe to pass. If partner doubles I pass and (assuming they don't run to 2S) I lead the ace of clubs.

[P_Marlowe]

Your options are Pass, awaiting the partners reopening double
or 3C, assuming this showes an inv. hand.
Given partner shortage, you know he has at least 4 clubs.

Since 3C may or may not show an inv. hand, I would suggest
you go with double, that you hold only low spot cards gets
compensated by the fact, that you have 5 hearts.
Lead the Ace and see, if you have to switch.

With kind regards
Marlowe