Is this a forcing pass situation?
#1
Posted 2007-October-16, 11:01
(2♣)-P-(3♣)-4♥;
(P) - P-(5♣)...
after opps make the 5♣ call, are we in a forcing pass situation?
#3
Posted 2007-October-16, 11:16
pclayton, on Oct 16 2007, 12:06 PM, said:
Sorry Phil, the correct answer is "heck no!"
#4
Posted 2007-October-16, 11:43
#5
Posted 2007-October-16, 11:55
It was mentioned that when it is clear that the opponents made the last bid without any intention that the contract was making, perhaps it is now a forcing pass situation. That makes a lot of sense to me. LHO made a non-forcing 3♣ call and then bid 5♣ after his partner passed over your 4♥ call. It is absolutely clear that the 5♣ call was not bid to make; hence, we cannot let them play in 5♣ undoubled.
So why is a pass over 5♣ not a forcing pass?
#6
Posted 2007-October-16, 12:11
ArtK78, on Oct 16 2007, 09:55 AM, said:
It was mentioned that when it is clear that the opponents made the last bid without any intention that the contract was making, perhaps it is now a forcing pass situation. That makes a lot of sense to me. LHO made a non-forcing 3♣ call and then bid 5♣ after his partner passed over your 4♥ call. It is absolutely clear that the 5♣ call was not bid to make; hence, we cannot let them play in 5♣ undoubled.
So why is a pass over 5♣ not a forcing pass?
Because:
1. RHO might have been walking the dog
2. RHO is bidding 5♣ as a 2-way shot (maybe he thinks he can make 5♣ or maybe he thinks we can make 4♥) or both.
3. RHO is nuts
or...
4. Our 4♥ call has caused RHO to re-evaluate and that 5♣ isn't so crazy after all.
#7
Posted 2007-October-16, 12:21
So the question is if the 4♥ bid promises enough strength to set up an FP.
#8
Posted 2007-October-16, 12:23
#9
Posted 2007-October-16, 13:01
whereagles, on Oct 16 2007, 01:23 PM, said:
Partner has made one meaningful call in the auction - his pass over 2♣. Neither his initial pass nor his pass over 4♥ denied a hand with some values. His pass over 2♣ limited his hand, but not to a flat hand with 0-2 HCP.
Partner's hand is still relatively undefined, except that I would be surprised if he had a good suit with more than 5 HCP or a flat hand with more than 7 HCP.
It is unlikely that RHO is walking the dog, since there was a very good chance that his 3♣ bid was going to end the auction when he bid it. A two-way shot is possible, but I would bet that he expects to make 9 or 10 tricks when he bids 5♣. Unfortunately, we were not given the vulnerability or the form of scoring when the problem was presented.
Is RHO nuts? That is a possibility.
In any event, my bidding clearly showed a very powerful hand, willing to play game opposite nothing in a live auction with both opponents bidding. While one may be able to construct a hand consistent with the bidding on which it is right to pass out 5♣ undoubled, I suspect that it will be right to either double them or bid on on a vast majority of hands.
Therefore, if I pass over 5♣, it should be a forcing pass.
#10
Posted 2007-October-16, 13:17
pclayton, on Oct 16 2007, 01:11 PM, said:
This is the real reason. Give him five clubs and xxx(x) of hearts.
Whereagles has a real point here. A forcing pass just transfers the guess to partner, who will be too weak to have a good idea of what is right.
#11
Posted 2007-October-16, 14:13
I wouldn't play this as a forcing pass.
- hrothgar
#12
Posted 2007-October-16, 14:23
Hannie, on Oct 16 2007, 08:13 PM, said:
I wouldn't play this as a forcing pass.
you are driving the wrong way!
#13
Posted 2007-October-16, 16:42
Hannie, on Oct 16 2007, 03:13 PM, said:
I wouldn't play this as a forcing pass.
como?
#14
Posted 2007-October-16, 16:43
#15
Posted 2007-October-16, 17:21
Fluffy, on Oct 16 2007, 03:23 PM, said:
Hannie, on Oct 16 2007, 08:13 PM, said:
I wouldn't play this as a forcing pass.
you are driving the wrong way!
I think I posted in the wrong thread, I meant to react to the leaping michaels question.
- hrothgar
#16
Posted 2007-October-16, 18:45
Instead, he doubled and then jumped, so he does not have a one-dimensional hand. He has power.
Sure, the odds are that partner is broke or close to broke, but FP decisions are not made exclusively on high card strength. Advancer has NOT had a chance to describe his (weakish or worse) hand. He denied the ability to bid over 2♣, and could hardly be bidding over 4♥, but that still leaves a very wide range of hands.
The 4♥ bidder has a hand that may make 11 tricks in hearts opposite a suitable minimum and not get rich against 5♣.
This has all the hallmarks of a FP. The opps could have played 3♣. We bid a game in a power sequence... we clearly expected to make at least 10 tricks while the opps had contracted, voluntarily, for 9.
I will NEVER allow the speculation that the opps are walking the dog to deflect me from thinking logically about the hand. BTW, if they are walking the dog, then I assure you that 5♥ will be a cheap save
#17
Posted 2007-October-16, 19:05
I'm well aware that this agreement seems to be non-standard.
a.k.a. Appeal Without Merit
#18
Posted 2007-October-16, 19:16
awm, on Oct 16 2007, 08:05 PM, said:
I'm well aware that this agreement seems to be non-standard.
This includes when you open 2♣?
#19
Posted 2007-October-16, 19:23
jdonn, on Oct 16 2007, 08:16 PM, said:
Yes. Typically I play an agreement where "pass shows values" over direct interference, so this is indeed a "forcing pass" (but doesn't violate the rule about no forcing passes when one partner could have zero).
On the other hand, I would not consider the following auction as forcing:
2♣ (strong) - Pass - 2♥ (0-2 hcp) - 3♦ - Pass....
or even:
2♣ (strong) - Pass - 2♦ (waiting, could be neg) - 3♦ - Pass...
another one I don't consider forcing is:
1NT (weak) - X (penalty) - 2♣ (natural NF) - Pass...
a.k.a. Appeal Without Merit
#20
Posted 2007-October-17, 02:12
I would say no, but my partner would say yes.
His reason being, 4H was bid to make, i.e. the bid
it self said, the partnership has enough strength to
make game.
In theory I agree with him, but I may bid differently
on the table.
With kind regards
Marlowe
Uwe Gebhardt (P_Marlowe)

Help
