Hannie, on Oct 17 2007, 05:24 PM, said:
If the rest of the field is in a making partscore then it really doesn't matter if you double. If they were going down then you would have had a top anyway, and if they make it then you would have had a bottom anyway.
Assuming that the double doesn't change the odds that they make it (not 100% clear I admit), you only have to compare the scores with the other pairs who are in game.
So if they make it more than 50% of the time then double will lower your expected MP score, and if they make it less than 50% of the time then double raises your expected MP score.
This isn't quite true, because the likelyhood that game makes and the likelyhood that the other pairs are in game may be correlated.
Let me make a simple toy example: Let's suppose the rest of the field is completely uniform, will be playing in spades, and either all of them play in 3S or in 4S, and that the contract is either taking 9 or 10 tricks at all tables. Let's say the chance that the rest of the field is in game is 50%, and that we are
- 70% likely to beat it when the other pairs are not in game, and
- 40% likely to beat it when the other pairs are in game.
Then we are obviously more than 50% likely to beat it, but it is also obviously losing tactics to double.
Of course this is pretty artificial, but I think there is some truth to this model - if the other pairs are in game as well, there is a better chance that our opponents have judged correctly, and that game will make.
The easiest way to count losers is to line up the people who talk about loser count, and count them. -Kieran Dyke