pclayton, on Oct 12 2007, 09:22 AM, said:
I think you can construct situations where any suit can work (seriously).
I'll go along with the tap defense like Han. I'm not so much worried about a 'safe' lead here.
2nd choice is a club which may foul communications.
I just don't see how a tap will ever beat this. Sometimes it will lead to down many when we are beating it anyway, but I think it is highly unlikely that a tap will give us a second trick. Spades are likely 5440, and hearts 6610. Say the first one is ruffed by the short hand, then declarer drives out our trump ace, ruffs the heart continuation, pulls our trump, and cashes his minor winners (assuming he has no loser there).
If he has to ruff with the long hand at trick one, he just plays 3 rounds of trumps, now if we take the ace and force he can ruff with this remaining small trump, cross to the other hand, and pull my trump.
If hearts are 5431 then probably the short hand has a heart void to justify his 6
♠ call. It seems only when hearts are 5431 and the overcaller has a heart void the force will work.
I think the way to beat this is just to hope that declarer has to finesse into my
♦K, or that otherwise we have a slow trick in a minor (e.g. declarer misguessing clubs).
If you think you have to build a trick you should lead
♦9 IMO.
The easiest way to count losers is to line up the people who talk about loser count, and count them. -Kieran Dyke