That's true Arend, but do we need the forcing pass here to help partner? Partner knows that we expected to make 4H with very little help. Without the forcing pass we have available:
Double = Enough strength to beat 5C by ourselves. Partner may still pull to 5H if he thinks that will score better.
Pass = Not enough power to guarantee setting 5C or making 5H. Partner will usually either double 5C or bid 5H, but may pass with nothing useful for 5H and perhaps something on defense.
5H = what it means anyway.
It is not entirely clear to me whether the forcing pass will make it easier for partner. More importantly, I think we usually don't play forcing passes in such situations.
Is this a forcing pass situation?
#41
Posted 2007-October-18, 14:06
Please note: I am interested in boring, bog standard, 2/1.
- hrothgar
- hrothgar
#42
Posted 2007-October-18, 14:09
Oh I wasn't saying that it is right to play forcing pass here, I was just disagreeing with Phil's logic "noone can have a slam try ==> pass can't be forcing" (if I understood Phil correctly).
The easiest way to count losers is to line up the people who talk about loser count, and count them. -Kieran Dyke
#43
Posted 2007-October-18, 14:22
Ah ok, agree of course.
Please note: I am interested in boring, bog standard, 2/1.
- hrothgar
- hrothgar
#44
Posted 2007-October-18, 15:16
cherdano, on Oct 18 2007, 12:09 PM, said:
Oh I wasn't saying that it is right to play forcing pass here, I was just disagreeing with Phil's logic "noone can have a slam try ==> pass can't be forcing" (if I understood Phil correctly).
I just floated the question for discussion.
I think occasionally its useful to have a forcing pass because you really don't know what to do, but that seems to me thats what a double in this case means. We have already shown a very offensive hand and if a pass was forcing, obviously we would be sitting for pard's double.
Pard heard our strong sequence, and could compete himself if necessary. Even if pass isn't forcing, pard isn't barred. I would expect in some cases that pard can double with short hearts and an outside trick, or that pard can compete with trump support and maybe shortness. Aren't these the kind of hands a forcing pass caters to?
OTOH, pard will more typically hold a 4=2=4=3 in this auction and not have a clue what to do over a 'forcing pass'. Aren't these the kinds of hands that we want pard to pass? Do we really have to double 5♣ for -1, just because in a vacuum pass should theoretically be forcing?
I really don't have any set opinions here, I'm just questioning the wisdom of a FP in this sequence.
One more thing. I've always believed that FP rules should be very simple. You gain a sliver of accuracy for bidding, but the penalty for being wrong can be very expensive.
"Phil" on BBO
#45
Posted 2007-October-19, 08:06
pclayton, on Oct 18 2007, 09:16 PM, said:
One more thing. I've always believed that FP rules should be very simple. You gain a sliver of accuracy for bidding, but the penalty for being wrong can be very expensive.
That is very, very true.

Help
