After the GF Second Suit Expert Practice in Transfer Auctions
#1
Posted 2007-October-15, 19:27
1N-2♦-2♥-3♦-3♠
is NOT to play this new-suit bid below 3N primarily as a cue, but as a concentration that tends to imply a problem in stopping the fourth suit.
While showing stoppers is a common practice over many minor-suit auctions, I don't believe that it is common, or wise, to do so here. Please let us know how you would play this bid, as well as whether you believe there is an expert consensus in this area.
#2
Posted 2007-October-15, 19:40
#3
Posted 2007-October-15, 19:46
Of course none of the above means if partner(responder) rebids 3nt that you cannot pass.
Axxx....Qx...Axxx....AJT
#4
Posted 2007-October-15, 20:11
#5
Posted 2007-October-15, 20:43
bhall, on Oct 15 2007, 08:27 PM, said:
1N-2♦-2♥-3♦-3♠
is NOT to play this new-suit bid below 3N primarily as a cue, but as a concentration that tends to imply a problem in stopping the fourth suit.
No I haven't! Lordy lord lord. It is either a cuebid for the second suit, or implies weakness in the unbid suit (essentially the same as saying it shows spades, since you will always bid a real spade suit unless your clubs are very strong). That is standard, and is not even included among your choices. Some will also do this as a cuebid for the major but it is much more common (and surely better, for simplification) to just bid the major with support.
The correct answer is "some of the above".
#6
Posted 2007-October-15, 20:48
cherdano, on Oct 15 2007, 09:11 PM, said:
With all due respect I would be shocked if 50% of Top class players play 3s=spades, ok...even 30%.
In other words...Ax of spades is just fine.
#7
Posted 2007-October-15, 20:49
mike777, on Oct 15 2007, 08:46 PM, said:
Of course none of the above means if partner(responder) rebids 3nt that you cannot pass.
Axxx....Qx...Axxx....AJT
As always, I agree 100% with Mike777.
ROTFLOL!!!!!
Seriously, though, I play that the bid of the other major agrees diamonds, whereas 3♦ would agree clubs if clubs was the other minor, allowing the other major in a major-club auction to be natural.
All real experts agree with me and Mike777, of course.
More rotflol!!!
-P.J. Painter.
#8
Posted 2007-October-15, 22:14
jdonn, on Oct 15 2007, 09:43 PM, said:
bhall, on Oct 15 2007, 08:27 PM, said:
1N-2♦-2♥-3♦-3♠
is NOT to play this new-suit bid below 3N primarily as a cue, but as a concentration that tends to imply a problem in stopping the fourth suit.
No I haven't! Lordy lord lord. It is either a cuebid for the second suit, or implies weakness in the unbid suit (essentially the same as saying it shows spades, since you will always bid a real spade suit unless your clubs are very strong). That is standard, and is not even included among your choices. Some will also do this as a cuebid for the major but it is much more common (and surely better, for simplification) to just bid the major with support.
The correct answer is "some of the above".
Sorry if I over-interpreted. Is it then accurate to say that you believe most experts play it as including three possibilities: (1) No stop in the 4th suit, only in the suit bid; (2) Cue in support of responder's second suit; and (3) An alternate trump suit for game? If so, it would appear that responder has somehow to field all three possibilties in his rebids.
Responder's 3N rebid in particular looks dicey without discussion. Is his first duty to show a firm ♣ stop, assuming that you don't have a fit, unless he can play 5♦ on his own opposite Hxx? Or does 3N assume that you do have a fit, so that he is offering a choice of contracts with only mild slam interest? Or is 3N also ambiguous?
Is 4♦ responder's default rebid without a firm ♣ stop, e.g., with 2=5=4=2? And is 4♥ over 3♠ then simply choice of games?
I am not trying to be sarcastic, I honestly don't know to what extent you believe expert practice has defined these auctions.
#9
Posted 2007-October-15, 23:53
I do have sympathy for Arend's treatment and I wonder if it would have been more common if transfers had been invented after the practice op opening 1NT with a 5-card major.
There is not much bidding space left so we cannot have our cake and eat it. Probably a creative use of
1N-2♦
2♥-2♠*
would solve the problem. After all, playing Smolen, this bid is not so common in it's natural meaning.
#10
Posted 2007-October-16, 01:22
1N-2♦-2♥-3♦-?
3♥ = ♦ Fit
3♠ = ♠ values, problem in ♣
3NT = To play
4♣ = Double fit, cue
4♦ = ♥ fit, good hand
4♥ = ♥ fit, bad hand
#11
Posted 2007-October-16, 02:05
helene_t, on Oct 15 2007, 11:53 PM, said:
I do have sympathy for Arend's treatment and I wonder if it would have been more common if transfers had been invented after the practice op opening 1NT with a 5-card major.
Huh I must have explained this very badly because I agree 100% with Josh.
#12
Posted 2007-October-16, 02:52
cherdano, on Oct 16 2007, 09:05 AM, said:
helene_t, on Oct 15 2007, 11:53 PM, said:
I do have sympathy for Arend's treatment and I wonder if it would have been more common if transfers had been invented after the practice op opening 1NT with a 5-card major.
Huh I must have explained this very badly because I agree 100% with Josh.
You didn't state that it implies club weakness. A few months back, a partner bid 3♠ with AJxxx and KQx in the unbid suits because 3♠ is "natural", I presume you would not?
#13
Posted 2007-October-16, 02:58
I'd see it as a cue with fit for the second suit. With fit for the first suit (here ♥), you can just bid 3♥.

Help
