Advancing Light II
#5
Posted 2007-October-12, 09:16
(And I'd pass with stronger hands as well)
#6
Posted 2007-October-12, 09:19
Even playing with Matt, I think I'd pass and we respond very light to 1♣.
Since its MPs, I think this is by far what the field will do.
If you bid, I think you need to show the director an example of a hand that passes 1♣.
#7
Posted 2007-October-12, 09:33
As an aside, but a relevant one (somewhat). I used to play with a guy where the specific auction 1♣-P-1NT showed 2-5 HCP's. The more vulnerable, the more minor cards you needed.
So, red-v-white, I experienced a winning auction that may never be repeated.
1♣(standard)-P-1NT(2-5, lots of minor cards)-X-
6♣(!!!)-P-P-X-P-P-P.
The play of the hand was neat. If a finesse worked, we would make 6♣ but would have set 5♥ or 5♠ one trick. If our finesse failed, 6♣ would be set one trick, for -200, but then 5♥ or 5♠ would have made (-450).
Use that for what you will.
-P.J. Painter.
#8
Posted 2007-October-12, 09:36
1♣-P-1♦-X
3♣-All pass
Sitting E/W what are my partner and I supposed to do about this? I feel confident that we're going to make 3NT if we're there. We didn't get a terrible board here, obviously, but it wasn't great.
#9
Posted 2007-October-12, 09:40
kfay, on Oct 12 2007, 07:36 AM, said:
1♣-P-1♦-X
3♣-All pass
Sitting E/W what are my partner and I supposed to do about this? I feel confident that we're going to make 3NT if we're there. We didn't get a terrible board here, obviously, but it wasn't great.
What to do?
West has an auto penalty double of 3♣. Looks like 800 or 1100 country to me.
#11
Posted 2007-October-12, 09:45
This NS pair wasn't bidding very well to put it mildly. This kind of bidding obvious creates a lot of crazy results and some of them will be to the advantage of NS.
#12
Posted 2007-October-12, 10:39
pclayton, on Oct 12 2007, 09:40 AM, said:
Did you read the auction wrong? West made a takeout double for the majors, he can't make a penalty double of 3♣ IMO. If you mean East, I would play his double of 3♣ as responsive.
Takeout doubles are not a good agreement against pairs who tend to play 3♣ on a 5-1 fit I guess.
#13
Posted 2007-October-12, 10:59
West has promised (normally) 4-4 in the majors. What is the value of a responsive double in this auction? If east has a major he can bid it. If east really wants west to pick a major he can bid 3♦.
On the other hand, a penalty situation is not unusual here since west often has short clubs and east could easily have a stack behind declarer. And west has already doubled once at vulnerable, it's silly to expect him to double again at the three-level without substantial extras.
This is not even a fit-showing auction (south never showed any clubs at all).
a.k.a. Appeal Without Merit
#14
Posted 2007-October-12, 11:06
cherdano, on Oct 12 2007, 08:39 AM, said:
pclayton, on Oct 12 2007, 09:40 AM, said:
Did you read the auction wrong? West made a takeout double for the majors, he can't make a penalty double of 3♣ IMO. If you mean East, I would play his double of 3♣ as responsive.
Takeout doubles are not a good agreement against pairs who tend to play 3♣ on a 5-1 fit I guess.
Arend I didn't read the auction wrong.
Some play the double by responder as responsive, but I think thats a minority view.
Put it this way, responsive doubles can continue ad absurdum...
1♣ - ? Double would be takeout..
1♣ - pass - pass - double
2♣ - double
Responsive right?
1♣ - pass - pass - double
3♣ - double
Responsive....
1♣ - pass - pass - double
4♣ - double
RESPONSIVE?
1♣ - pass - pass - double
2♣ - pass - pass - 2 major
3♣ - ...now?
Whats a poor fella to do when he's dealt trump over the bidder when pard is kind enough to make a TOx?
#15
Posted 2007-October-12, 11:09
#16
Posted 2007-October-12, 12:10
#17
Posted 2007-October-12, 12:15
ArtK78, on Oct 12 2007, 08:10 PM, said:
I don't think so. W does not need to have 15 points.
#18
Posted 2007-October-12, 12:19
I have made a few 3NT contracts with less than 25 HCP. Besides, partner doubled into a live auction opposite a passed hand. Partner should have a good hand.
#20
Posted 2007-October-13, 04:43

Help

1♣-P-?