Another BB Hand
#1
Posted 2007-October-10, 16:46
♠AT
♥J9
♦AQx
♣AKQJxx
Playing in the bermuda bowl against world class opponents, you get a weak 2♦ opening on your right. What's your call?
a.k.a. Appeal Without Merit
#2
Posted 2007-October-10, 16:52
#3
Posted 2007-October-10, 16:56
cherdano, on Oct 10 2007, 05:52 PM, said:
Is (2♦)-DBL-(P)-3M; (P)-4♣ natural or a cue-bid for M?
#5
Posted 2007-October-10, 17:35
TimG, on Oct 10 2007, 05:56 PM, said:
cherdano, on Oct 10 2007, 05:52 PM, said:
Is (2♦)-DBL-(P)-3M; (P)-4♣ natural or a cue-bid for M?
Natural, I would be shocked if there could even be any debate about that.
Edit: I didn't answer the question. I prefer double then bidding clubs, I think slam potential is too good for 3NT though I appreciate the reasoning behind that bid.
Further edit: I meant bidding clubs if it is an auction where that will be forcing (like if partner bids 3M), obviously if partner bids 2♥ or something I'm too good for that.
#6
Posted 2007-October-10, 20:04
- hrothgar
#8
Posted 2007-October-11, 00:34
(2♦) 3 NT and
(2 ♦) X (pass) 3 Major (pass) 3 NT
Heck in this case, I will even know, whether the later case is not serious 3NT and agreeing the major...
If x followed by 4 Club shows clubs and X followed 3 NT shows a natural NT, but too strong for a direct 3 NT bid, then we must put all strong raises in the cuebid, with or without a control.
We had the discussion before and many people like to play it this way but I am still not convinced that this approach will work for me.
I´ll go with a direct 3 NT bid to show this hand. I am allowed to have maximum once in a while.
Roland
Sanity Check: Failure (Fluffy)
More system is not the answer...
#9
Posted 2007-October-11, 04:44
Maybe dbl could lead to a bad result if p jumps to 4M, or bid 4♦over LHO's 3♦ with both majors.
I think 3N describes this hand well, but maybe I'm too strong for this. In Croatia I once jumped to 3N over a 1-level opening with a similar hand, and p thought my hand was too good.
#11
Posted 2007-October-11, 08:33
#12
Posted 2007-October-11, 10:00
Dbl, and then we'll see.
#13
Posted 2007-October-11, 10:23
For double to be right:
- Pard needs to hold 2 of the 3 of the ♠K or ♥AK
- Pard needs to be able to ruff our third diamond successfully
- Double needs to lead to a sensible sequence to slam, whereas 3N won't.
Double can be very wrong if:
- Pard wants to insist on a major, holding say a 5-5 in hearts and spades.
- It can be wrong if it helps LHO to lead a heart
- If pard mis-evaluates. What exactly does double then 3N over 2 major mean versus a direct 3N? I'd say it shows a big balanced hand, not a big source of tricks.
#15
Posted 2007-October-11, 12:07
Another element to consider is how undefined a double is here in context. A cunning LHO might psyche a major here, or make a lead directing bid of 3♣. You're not only no better off than you were, but it might just talk pard out of a call.
I am like Phil here; shortcutting to the sure positive barring something drastic.
#16
Posted 2007-October-11, 18:55
In the South Africa vs. USA1 Semi-final, 2♦ was opened by South Africa and south chose double. The auction:
2♦ - X - 3♦ - 4♦
P - 4nt - P - 5♠
P - 7♣ - P - 7♥
A/P
They played in the 4-2 fit at the seven level, off the trump ace! Down two. Huge result for SA right? Not exactly... in the other room the USA player opened 3♦, and south also chose double:
3♦ - X - 4♦ - 5♦
P - 6♦ - P - 6♠
P - 7NT - X - A/P
So they played 7NTX, off a cashing ace, down one. Push Board.
In the other semi-final match, neither pair was playing a weak two in diamonds. One team had a relatively unobstructed auction to 6NT, and the other reached 6♣ after an artificial 2♣ opening showing either a strong hand or a weak two in diamonds.
I would've bid 3NT, for what it's worth. Not clear how easy it is to reach slam after that start, but playing in a grand slam off a cashing ace seems unlikely.
a.k.a. Appeal Without Merit
#18
Posted 2007-October-11, 19:21
#19
Posted 2007-October-12, 08:12
#20
Posted 2007-October-12, 09:41
My partner and I came in second. I got here tickled by asking when I could sign up for her lesson series.
Now, I'm wondering who else signed up.
-P.J. Painter.

Help
