hrothgar, on Oct 8 2007, 06:14 AM, said:
I think that the results of the South Africa - Italy match expose some of the limitations with the modeling techniques that folks have been using:
The approach that I have been advocating (and that Gerben and Alex implemented) is based on Monte Carlo simulation. To date, the model that we were using made an explicite assumption that the expected value and the variance for board results was constant across the length of a match. A more sophisitcated model should probably build in the notion of deliberately trading off expected value for variance when one is behind by a large amount. I don't think that this would be that much more difficult to program, however, parameterizing the model would become a lot more difficult.
From what I can tell, Helene's approach suffered from a different problem. A number of follks, myself included seemed to feel that Helene's model gave a bot too much credit to the Italians. In particular, the model suggested that the Italians were massive favorites against a number of teams that beat them in head-to-head matches during the Round Robin stage. (In defference to Helene, it seems clear that the Italians also believed that they were clear favorites to beat the SA team despite losing to SA in the RR). I suspect that Helene's model may have fallen victim to one of my favorite theories: Bridge isn't transitive (furthermore, I beleive that Helene's model does have transitivity assumptions built into it). While Italy lost to SA, they scored well against a number of teams that SA didn't fare quite so well against. In turn, this suggested that the Italy v SA was an outlier....
I think it is much simpler than that. Bridge maybe isn't transitive, but I would think this effect is very very small.
The simple explanation is:
1. South Africa played better in the quarter-final than in the Round Robin, and the Italians (well, maybe just one of their pairs) worse. I don't think Helene's model allowed for that.
2. South Africa had more luck than Italy in the quarter final.
The easiest way to count losers is to line up the people who talk about loser count, and count them. -Kieran Dyke