Who will stop Italy?
#1
Posted 2007-October-04, 09:43
- hrothgar
#3
Posted 2007-October-04, 10:56
If Italy is 100% to make it to the quarter-finals, 10 to 1 to win their quarter-final match, and 5 to 1 to win both their semi-final and final matches, they are still less than 60% to win the whole thing.
And even though most people would probably consider Italy to be "clearly the best team", I suspect that most of these people would believe that there are several other teams that have a better than 1 in 5 chance of beating Italy in a given match.
So I think you need to work on your imagination
Fred Gitelman
Bridge Base Inc.
www.bridgebase.com
#5
Posted 2007-October-04, 11:10
USA2 seems to be recovering from a fairly slow start. They're currently sitting in the middle of the pack with a fairly easy schedule for the next couple days (Egypt, New Zealand, Pakistan, Indonesia, and the Netherlands). The might be able to pick up 3-4 places and make it in to the finals.
On a good day, either USA1 or USA2 is a good match for the Italians.
#6
Posted 2007-October-04, 11:19
Robert
#7
Posted 2007-October-04, 11:51
matmat, on Oct 4 2007, 09:04 AM, said:
Look at Tiger's match play record in the Ryder Cup. Not that impressive.
He played well in this year's President's Cup, although he lost an emotional head to head match to Mike Weir of Canada in the singles that didn't affect the result.
He also has a spotty record in the annual Match Play championship they have in the spring on the PGA tour.
Tiger versus the field is one thing. He's the best in the world and they guy you'd want to put your money on. Tiger vs. Player A, then Player B, etc.. is less impressive.
So, yeah, if you had to pick a favorite, its Italy at this point, but they are much worse than a 2:1 favorite at this point.
#8
Posted 2007-October-04, 11:56
#9
Posted 2007-October-04, 12:02
#10
Posted 2007-October-04, 12:02
#11
Posted 2007-October-04, 12:49
#12
Posted 2007-October-04, 13:11
Italy: 35%%
USA1: 25%
Poland: 15%
USA2: 10%
Norway: 10%
Other: 5%
or some such. Actually my linear regression model could compute the chances, but one would have to make some assumptions. In the most simple case one could assume that the strength of the teams don't change during the event.
#13
Posted 2007-October-04, 13:30
You know, we Italians are very superstitious...
(Mahan Khalsa)
#14
Posted 2007-October-04, 14:11
helene_t, on Oct 4 2007, 02:11 PM, said:
Italy: 35%%
USA1: 25%
Poland: 15%
USA2: 10%
Norway: 10%
Other: 5%
I also think Netherlands has a very good team
#15
Posted 2007-October-04, 14:42
#16
Posted 2007-October-04, 14:49
Elianna, on Oct 4 2007, 03:42 PM, said:
because only advanced and expert players can answer questions of this magnitude.
#17
Posted 2007-October-04, 15:29
But there's several teams in the competition who's got a 40-50% chance of beating them in a head to head match, and has done so on more than one occasion over the last 5-6 years.
The Italian team haven't IMO looked quite as impressive as earlier the last year, and certainly not in the first part of the Round Robin. I'd give them 25-30% chance of winning the event now, after they have gotten their play more together now. I'd say USA1 20-25%, Poland and USA2 15%, Norway and Netherlands 10%, Other 10-20%.
Harald
#18
Posted 2007-October-04, 19:30
pclayton, on Oct 5 2007, 05:51 AM, said:
matmat, on Oct 4 2007, 09:04 AM, said:
Look at Tiger's match play record in the Ryder Cup. Not that impressive.
He played well in this year's President's Cup, although he lost an emotional head to head match to Mike Weir of Canada in the singles that didn't affect the result.
He also has a spotty record in the annual Match Play championship they have in the spring on the PGA tour.
Tiger versus the field is one thing. He's the best in the world and they guy you'd want to put your money on. Tiger vs. Player A, then Player B, etc.. is less impressive.
So, yeah, if you had to pick a favorite, its Italy at this point, but they are much worse than a 2:1 favorite at this point.
I think this is just an argument about the length of matches.
Tiger vs Player A etc over 18 holes is something of a lottery.
Tiger vs Player A etc over many more holes is a whole lot different.
Similarly in bridge anyone can and do win 16 board matches but when it comes to the longer matches in the knockout there will be more certainty on the outcome - the better team will win more often. Although quite possibly the matches aren't long enough to ensure that Italy is better than 5 to 1 on.
I believe that the USA currently hold only the World Championship For People Who Still Bid Like Your Auntie Gladys - dburn
dunno how to play 4 card majors - JLOGIC
True but I know Standard American and what better reason could I have for playing Precision? - Hideous Hog
Bidding is an estimation of probabilities SJ Simon
#19
Posted 2007-October-04, 19:46
fred, on Oct 4 2007, 12:56 PM, said:
If Italy is 100% to make it to the quarter-finals, 10 to 1 to win their quarter-final match, and 5 to 1 to win both their semi-final and final matches, they are still less than 60% to win the whole thing.
No offense, Fred, but the "math" you're considering assumes that all the events are random and independent. But bridge matches are not like rolling dice.
#20
Posted 2007-October-05, 03:27
barmar, on Oct 5 2007, 03:46 AM, said:
fred, on Oct 4 2007, 12:56 PM, said:
If Italy is 100% to make it to the quarter-finals, 10 to 1 to win their quarter-final match, and 5 to 1 to win both their semi-final and final matches, they are still less than 60% to win the whole thing.
No offense, Fred, but the "math" you're considering assumes that all the events are random and independent. But bridge matches are not like rolling dice.
Nope. They cannot win (or lose) the semi-final without having won the quarterfinal, so the "5 to 1" thing is a conditional probability. Hence dependency is mood.
Fred is right, as always

Help
