From a local club game:
North
S-K54
H-J8652
D-7
C-KT84
South
S-Void
H-K
D-AKQ984
C-AQJ953
South West North East
1D Pass 1H 1S
3C Pass 3NT Pass
4C Pass 5C Pass
6C All Pass
Spade led, making 7. Diamonds were 3-3
Enough said
Page 1 of 1
A cute hand
#1
Posted 2003-September-10, 11:33
Please do not complain about my opinion. I don't have the time to convince you I'm right.
#2
Posted 2003-September-10, 11:47
I would've opened 1C, because 1D followed by 3C isn't absolute forcing, but a reverse is...
And yes, it's a cute hand
And yes, it's a cute hand
"It may be rude to leave to go to the bathroom, but it's downright stupid to sit there and piss yourself" - blackshoe
#3
Posted 2003-September-10, 11:52
Quote
I would've opened 1C, because 1D followed by 3C isn't absolute forcing, but a reverse is...
And yes, it's a cute hand
And yes, it's a cute hand
Thanks for the reply
I don't know where you are from, but where I learned to play, 1D followed by 3C is a Game force. Plus, we NEVER reverse with equal length. A reverse ALWAYS shows mores cards in the first suit.
Please do not complain about my opinion. I don't have the time to convince you I'm right.
#4
Posted 2003-September-10, 17:27
"I don't know where you are from, but where I learned to play, 1D followed by 3C is a Game force. Plus, we NEVER reverse with equal length. A reverse ALWAYS shows mores cards in the first suit. "
We don't play it as a GF, but we DO play it as 100% forcing, and "yes", a reverse ALWAYS shows that the first bid suit is longer and this is standard in ANY system unless you play some sort of canape.
Reminds me of a hand from Monday
Qx
void
AQJ9xx
AKJxx
opposite
Jxxxx
xxx
KTx
xx
1D (X) P (4H)
5C (P) 5D
All pass
Making 5 on the nose.
We don't play it as a GF, but we DO play it as 100% forcing, and "yes", a reverse ALWAYS shows that the first bid suit is longer and this is standard in ANY system unless you play some sort of canape.
Reminds me of a hand from Monday
Qx
void
AQJ9xx
AKJxx
opposite
Jxxxx
xxx
KTx
xx
1D (X) P (4H)
5C (P) 5D
All pass
Making 5 on the nose.
"The King of Hearts a broadsword bears, the Queen of Hearts a rose." W. H. Auden.
#5
Posted 2003-September-15, 17:27
Nice hand, just one question. Isn't this hand too strong to open 1D? Looking at the hand in general I can see two losers. I would have opted for a 2C opening.
#6
Posted 2003-September-15, 17:31
Nice hand, just one question. Isn't this hand too strong to open 1D? Looking at the hand in general I can see two losers. I would have opted for a 2C opening.
There is a school of thought that asserts that 2-suited hands should not be opened 2C.
The opening steals too much space and you never have enough room to describe your shape.
Personally, I agree
There is a school of thought that asserts that 2-suited hands should not be opened 2C.
The opening steals too much space and you never have enough room to describe your shape.
Personally, I agree
Alderaan delenda est
Page 1 of 1

Help
