I was thinking about the poll hand some more, and while that hand was solvable, many are not. If GIB is going to move over 2C-2D-2S-3C-4S with 9xx, xxxx, Jxxx, Qx, as it did on the poll hand, what is opener to do with AKQJTxx, xx, AK, Ax? You have game in hand but if you bid 4S over 3C GIB will push on to an unmakeable contract.
Once again the issue is that GIB can count points but cannot judge the value of long strong suits. No human would consider bidding over 4S with that hand, why does GIB insist on doing so?
Page 1 of 1
Poll Follow Up GIB needs to keep quiet with very weak hands
Page 1 of 1